Response to Pat W.
Peter S.

Pat W., in your essay you said that you were very disappointed in the way the hobbits looked. Well, you never said what was so wrong about them. I personally find them to look pretty much appropriate. They are dressed fine, and the actors seem like they will be able to fill their positions properly. If you would be so kind as to tell me(and everyone else on this forum) what your problems are maybe then I would be able to sympathize with your concerns. But until then I see no basis for your complaint, and I am hoping that you will back yourself up.