-
W
O
R
D
S
|
-
The LOTR Movie Site
October 9, 1999The Importance of
Tolkien Movies
PlayBumSp1
I can't say how many
interpretations I have read about the upcoming Lord of the Rings trilogy. And I
can't say how many I've disagreed with. Every writer emphasizes the importance of staying
with the books, and the idea that we (the Tolkien readers) all be satisfied. While these
are important, there are factors that everybody is missing.
Around 50 million books of Tolkien have been
sold, around the world. Nowadays, top movies in this country make over 20 million per week
on average. We all know this movie is going to open big, so we'll say that at the worst,
it make 25 million. Together, if ALL of us went to see the movie only once, because it
didn't follow the books, we'd cover two weeks. The money will be in pleasing the rest of
the world's population. If it pleases us, we will (most likely) make up that repeat
viewing that the companies so crave and desire. We, as well as those who will read the
book after the first movie, will make Lord of the Rings the Star Wars of the new
millennium (what a way to start the century). That's where the importance in pleasing us
comes in. No matter how much it stinks, the Trilogy will make money (Episode 1
stank, and look at the 400 million it raked in).
But for that matter don't sell Mr. Jackson short. He has been
nominated for an Oscar after all, and for writing! So we can at least be assured that the
script will be good, even if it's not the way we would have interpreted it. To show the
real importance of the books becoming movies, we have to go beyond that piece of the book
that we're worried won't be included in the films, who it will please and how much it will
please them etc. The fact is that before Star Wars came along, science fiction did not
have near the popularity that it did afterwards and probably wouldn't be as successful a
movie genre as it is today. Should this trilogy be successful, it will most likely start
(at the very least) a fad of fantasy movies. Should these movies be as well-planned out
and smart as Lord of the Rings appears to be, that sounds all well and good. But this
could also backfire.
I'm sure we can all remember those crappy sci-fi movies that
should have never made it into the theatres. Considering the quality of past fantasy
films, we might not want that. But if the movies can remain of high quality, I see no
reason why we wouldn't see more fantasy films in theatres. The entire genre (of both films
and of books) would get much more respect than they are currently. And we would get into
more varieties of action movies -- less shoot 'em ups and arms and armor. Gradual steps
have already been taken by actor Antonio Banderas (Zorro and The 13th Warrior).
While, admittedly, these movies needed a little help with their writing, they were a
welcome break from other action movies of the summer. And I wouldn't mind seeing more of
it. |