January 25, 2003

Aragorn?
Igor Wulff

I have seen the TTT and as a fan of Tolkien's works (Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit and The Silmarilion. I was dissapointed because of these things: - Faramir is just like his brother in the movie and I thought that he was the opposite and that he wouldn't want to have the Ring! Aragorn is to weak and he didn't fell from the cliff. He is a leader and a captain among people and he isn't someone that can be hurted when Orcs a few Orcs are attacking him because they are affraid for him and his Sword. Narsil or Anduril should be more as a character that just know when it should turn blue and lets the enemy fear the wealder of the sword. And Frodo with the Ring and the Nazgul, just awfull I can't imagine that Frodo is almost mastered by the Ring and that he want's to give it freely to a Ringwraith.
And there were so small amount of people at helmsdeep I mean Erkenbrand had still a lot of soldiers there defending the place. And Haldir shoudn't be there and I can't understand why he should be there in the movie. And Arwen in some roles that weren't neccesairry. These are the things I think were just very stupid to do. I understand that a lot of people think that this is just rubbish what I say and that I should see the film as something different than the book because a movie shouldn't be any bigger than 3 houers. I think that they should have made an exception for this story to honour the works of JRR Tolkien (I don't think he would like to have a movie made at all). I think that the movie is very good and Peter has done a good job in creating this movie. Because I think that others would have made the movie totally crap.