February 25, 2003

To Much Change
Firniswin

Hello,
I would like to start by saying that I liked TTT
but it was far from Tolkien, if you understand me, I mean ok. You got the book version of Galadriel now she is not evil! She looks it in TfotR, but don't believe everything you see, especially the fact that biblo and Frodo are cousins, the movie messed me totally up, I was answering quizzes that they were uncle and nephew.
And ok Plus they gave Arwen Glorfindel's part and horse. And for those who do not remember Glorfindel, Don't feel bad. He is not remembered by many. Plus there is old Bombadil, Gildor, Galdor, Radagast the brown, and many more who's names are left out.
And also Bilbo was supposed to be at the council of Elrond. But that is a small matter compared to the other stuff.
in the movie TTT Faramir is the most evil and wicked person I have ever seen,In the book Frodo and Sam are given a bed decent meal among the rangers, And are not dragged in opposite direction.
And not to make matters worse for the Arwen lovers out there but, She is not in the book TTT
at all, and frankly I am glad. She bothers me. Please donot attempt to ask why!
And there is that other matter with Aragorn falling over that cliff in the movie I donot remember that in the book. I mean it is nice how Aragorn is sooooooo deeply in love with Arwen that he must dream about her kissing him, PLEASE!
I absolutly loved Gimli and Legolas, they were hillarious. They were the best! I loved there little [ I can kill more orcs than you game].
Oh and what is up with Haldir's death? He does not die like that, he does die in battle but deffinetly not at Helm's Deep! He does not even go to helms Deep! Whatever?
And also why did they stop when they did? They still have half the book to go. And they better do the whole RotK plus the half of TTT that they left out!
Anyway that is my review on the movies compared to the books, hope you enjoyed! And please visit my site, please excuse the name. www.toppetz.homestead.com , I worked hard on it!
It has character reviews, polls, quizzes, puppies, FotR, TTT, and hard to find RotK pics. At least it was hard for me to fingd them. And there is much more.


written by
Firniswin of Mirkwood