March 12, 2003

Reply to the Happyscotsman on Arwen
Peter D.

Of course none of us (except for PJ and the rest of the initiated) really know what the scene of Arwen leaving Rivendell means in the plot further on, but a thing that struck me was that the expression on Elronds face isnt really the expression of a relieved parent, but more of one that is weighed heavily with the fate laid before him. Elronds almost aggressive (in a non-violent way)coaxing towards Arwen and her staying behind in the world of men, could be interpreted as someone who is ultimately fighting a losing battle and gradually more aware of that fact.

As for the sons of Elrond, well if PJ does not think that it would be too late to introduce them in the final installment, they may be there in the party - anyway it would seem unlikely that Elrond would send his daughter off without a strong following... but we´ll see.