June 4, 2003

Re: Pip - Valinor, Lilly, and G
Colin

I frequently come to this forum because, unlike similar ones, it's not categorised - thoughts on films and books are present, and I for one think this is very valuable.

Pip - Lilly may get on your nerves, but that's your problem. I'm assuming that she's only recently become immersed in the world of Tolkien, and understandably has a keen thirst for knowledge. The best way to gain this knowledge is on a forum like this one, so why is that a bad thing? My own opinions on many aspects of the books have been influenced by all the fresh perspectives I've gained from this forum, and I'm sure many others would agree with me.

So Lilly, keep posting, and ignore any negative comments from others! You've as much right to ask questions and give your opinions as anyone else!