June 27, 2003

Lilly and Pip Responces
Samwise

I have a few comments to talk about in responce to Lilly and Pip. Thanks for backing me Lilly though I do not wish to start a HP vs LOTR fight again. I just started writing because I found it enjoying to express myself. Another comment Lilly I agree with both your articles completely. And Sam is my favorite character in the book/movie trilogy. You just cant read HP after LOTR or it seems like nothing. On another note I agree with Pip also about the third movie time. If PJ to make the third movie as close to the third book as possible, then he is going to need more screening time than 3 hours. Especially since he did not finish the second book in the second movie. I would really enjoy the Scouring of the Shire, but from many sources I have heard it will not be included. A movie reviewer said an audience would not tolerate more action in the end of the movie after the Ring was destroyed and the war over. People would not like that, but I think (especially for the people who read the book) they would love to see that seen.
Well this is again my opinion and I think Lilly and
Pip do a great job writing articles in this forum and I hope to keep writing too.