August 17, 2003

Sauron/melkor Redemption Narsil/Anduril
Melkor

As to whether or not the Valar did enough trying to cure Melkor and then Sauron from there evil ways, they did all that they could. The reason they could not help Melkor was because he possessed a feeling/emotion that they had never comprehended, I believe it was envy or something. They could not help him once they took him captive the first time because they could not see the problem. It's in the Silmarillion but I dont have the book handy so I can't look up the exact emotion.

And since no one answered my first post regarding this why do I keep seeing articles about who will bring Aragorn Narsil in ROTK?????? Has he not had it since he left Rivendell?