January 13, 2004

Re: Uruviel
Frodo_Lives

Thats a really interesting thought but I think you are wrong. Now I would say you were right if I hadn't read the books.

The reson I say this is because Peter Jackson totally skipped the part in the book where Sam has the vision of himself tkaing the Ring for his own (after he takes the Ring from Frodo when he thought Frodo was dead) and turning Modor into a beautiful place and making the grass green and trees everywhere and basically make it one big Garden. And he invisions himself being hailed as like "Samwise the Brave" or some great kingly title. He was tempted but then good ol' hobbit sence kicked in and he knew he could never do it and he needed to go and save Mr. Frodo if he died trying. So that little part where Sam hesitates in giving the Ring back to Frodo is PJ's way of showing Sam being tempted. At least thats what I think.

Frodo Lives 4ever!

PS I am not sure if you had read the books or not thats why I explained that whole part of the book. Sometimes I completely forget little parts of the book like that so I was just reminding you. If you haven't read the books.... thats what happens!!! :-) Sam was tempted.