January 15, 2004

More About Selling the EE
Elendur

First: My brother wrote the first post about the Witch-King Gandalf scene, but I agree with him. It doesn't make sense to me that PJ put the landing of the Witch-King at the gate in the trailer and left the "I will brake him" in the movie but took out the scene that it leads up to. I admit there are possible reasons for dropping the confrontation from the movie: It might be anti-climatic having them meet but not fight, even though it made a good scene in the book. Can you think of a reason they left in the build up scene but took out the gate challenge?

Think I'm right, hope I'm wrong,

-Elendur