October 12, 2004

Best supporting actor
Lilly

Sean Astin did Sam very well...for the most part (though I its the writers that had Sam actually leave when Frodo told him to...grrrr).

I think Dom Monaghan and Billy Boyd took it, though. They were the perfect hobbits. Although Boyd may have been a bit older than Pippin was in the book (in relation to the other hobbits), he played the part swell. I can't wait for Merry's half of the story in the EE DVD this December 14th. Who else has already preordered?

Yours.

Lilly
PS: Liv Tyler flawless? In looks, well, yeah, but as an elf? As the part? I'd not call her flawless. Nor Hugo Weaving either, but I just don't like how Elrond was treated throughout the last two.