June 25, 2002

The Wrong Necklace
Kalimac the Green

About Arwens necklace, Aragorn is supposed to be given a necklace that was passed down from Galadriel to Celebrian to Arwen in the book. This necklace was given to him by Galadriel as we all know, and had a green stone. However, she gives a different necklace to Frodo in Return of the King, and the description of this second necklace fits the movie necklace perfectly. So whatever happened to the silver eagle with the green stone? That necklace was the whole reason Aragorn was called the Elfstone, but he has the wrong necklace! Has anyone else noticed this?

Also, in my previous Arwen article, i said she was at the Council of Elrond. Sorry, I just meant in Rivendell, no idea what i was thinking there.