August 7, 2002

Re: Annatar and the Walls of Minas Tirith
Curufinwe

Greetings everybody, I've been reading several posts and I wanted to respond to Annatar about the walls of Minas Tirith. Considering that the city is called the White City I think most of us would assume the walls are white. But who knows?

Also I'd like to say something in defence of Thauron (Sauron for all non-fans) and the Balrogs. In Valinor I don't think these Maiar were bad folk, but they just fell in with the wrong crowd namely Melkor. I believe that they were just living normally until one day Melkor asks them to take a walk with him and BOOM!!! they've become evil. Imagine how nice Arda would be without Melkor. I mean what kind of chip does he have on his shoulder abducting innocent Maiar? If our patron God Eru made one mistake it was creating Melkor.

If I have offended anyone with this post, I'm not really sorry. These are my comments and there is no other alternative.