|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Positive Spin on TTT Alterations
Posted by Ghan-buri-ghan on 02-03-03
I know I was disappointed when I first saw TTT in the cinema due to the...
In Defense of Faramir
Posted by Spathi on 02-03-03
I think people need to calm down about the whole Faramir thing. After...
Tellings and Retellings
Posted by Chris on 02-03-03
After the first time I saw "Fellowship", I came out...
Book Vs Film - How Can You Compare?
Posted by Elmo on 02-03-03
I managed to read Two Towers just in time for the film’s release. I had...
Re: Anduril
Posted by Brett C. on 02-04-03
Firstly, Faramir, let me say I have the utmost sympathy for you in the...
Osgiliath, Frodo, and Ringwraiths
Posted by Curious George on 02-04-03
This is my gut feeling on the whole issue: PJ chose to have Faramir...
Ichibo's Right
Posted by Matt Mcnabb on 02-04-03
I must say I agree with Ichibo about the fact that TTT diverged way too...
Audiences and Race
Posted by Tom on 02-04-03
I have noticed in my movie-goings that in FOTR (here in the Boston...
On the Characters
Posted by Mithril Miner on 02-04-03
To everyone who has been complaining about Faramir in the movie, I...
To Steve L. and 'Changes'
Posted by Scooter on 02-05-03
Steve L, I found your message interesting. It addressed worthwhile...
Mythology and Nature, Two Sides of One Coin
Posted by Philip Fontaine on 02-05-03
I just saw TTT and was struck by Tolkien's reference to nature...
You Have to Look Between the Lines
Posted by Brett C. on 02-05-03
Lots of articles about the changes in TTT. This one adresses points...
Broken Toe
Posted by Mizzle on 02-05-03
I was just reading Gwaihir's essay on The Two Tower's Blemishes...
About Angbands Location
Posted by Galactus on 02-05-03
For the Great Fish of Ulmo. Angband is in the far north of the world...
Understandable But...
Posted by Galactus on 02-05-03
To Gwaihir. I read your two-fold article on the problems you saw in...
Positive Spin on Ttt Alterations
Posted by Ghan-buri-ghan on 02-07-03
I know I was disappointed when I first saw TTT in the cinema due to the...
Elves and the Undying Lands
Posted by Turin Turambar on 02-07-03
Elves are leaving Middle earth because 1) the last of the rebel Noldor...
Re: Grey Havens
Posted by Danny on 02-07-03
To understand the departure of the elves best, you need to have read...
It's Soooo Easy
Posted by Francois on 02-07-03
First of all, I would like to say that I'm impressed with the quality of...
Braveheart
Posted by The Bruce, Stirling on 02-07-03
I was amused to find the film Braveheart being cited to discredit PJ's...
Re: Roman Circus
Posted by Mithril Miner on 02-07-03
I see your logic, Steve L, but I can not agree with you. Admittidly PJ...
Re: PJ's Roman Circus
Posted by Cris on 02-08-03
I can't agree with you more Steve. I have expressed these same...
Fishing for References
Posted by Brett C. on 02-08-03
Great Fish, about the only thing on the map of Beleriand that you will...
Circus Maximus
Posted by Brett C. on 02-08-03
Some thoughts about Steve L's article regarding the story telling in...
In Defense of Arwen
Posted by Judson on 02-08-03
Among my favorite scenes in TTT were those “added” scenes featuring...
Bread and Circuses
Posted by Tom M. on 02-08-03
I may have an advantage over some of the other fans of LOTR...
Movie V. Film, Or, Skate Boards V. Depth
Posted by Judy Ann on 02-08-03
I'd like to offer some thoughts I've not seen regrading departures from...
To Christian Hobbit
Posted by Wandering Wizard on 02-08-03
Dear fellow Tolkien fan, Thank you for your most recent article! It...
Book vs Film
Posted by Jane on 02-12-03
I managed to read Two Towers just in time for the film’s release. I had...
My Review...
Posted by Mark on 02-12-03
I wrote a long review about this movie shortly after the 1st of the...
Orcs and Uruk-hai
Posted by Mithril Miner on 02-12-03
The wierdest thing happened to me the other day. I was talking with my...
But Does It Work?
Posted by Matthew F. on 02-12-03
"Is the film faithful to the book?" There is more than one...
Differences From Book to Movie
Posted by Maureen Sullivan on 02-12-03
The addition of Arwen as a larger force in the film clears up otherwise...
Wormtongue
Posted by Andrew on 02-12-03
I believe that Wormtongue shedding that tear does signify him realizing...
Return of the King
Posted by Andrew on 02-13-03
Why does everybody think that Return of the King is gonna be so...
Not a Pointless Scene At All
Posted by Chambers on 02-13-03
Clearly Elrond's speech about why Arwen shouldn't stay with Aragorn...
The Defense of Faramir
Posted by Chambers on 02-13-03
This is in response to the many complaints about Faramir I have heard...
Response to Kailem About TTT Questions
Posted by Andrew on 02-13-03
Hello. Your questions about TTT are very good, and I have the...
Faramir - Eventual Hero
Posted by Bol on 02-13-03
I haven't posted on this site before, but here goes. I watched TTT...
Re: Satinder's Comments
Posted by Lughaidh on 02-13-03
Firstly, I humbly apologize for transposing the letters in your name and...
TTT Review
Posted by Wingfoot on 02-17-03
After seeing The Two Towers twice now, I must admit that I found a few...
Okay: Faramir
Posted by Brett C. on 02-17-03
Well, I finally have time to talk about what I think of the portrayal of...
Comments and Explanations
Posted by Derek Bessette on 02-17-03
Melkor, aka Morgoth (a parallel to Lucifer/Satan) did not create...
To Demian & Prettylil
Posted by Razors on 02-17-03
To Demian: I had yet another interpretation of Wormtongue's tear...
Logic in TTT
Posted by Danny on 02-17-03
Someone argued that the Wraith seeing the ring destroys Tolkien's...
Frodo in TTT
Posted by Danny on 02-17-03
Don't hate me for saying this, but Frodo's almost giving the ring to...
The Trolls in Question...
Posted by Galactus on 02-18-03
Keep in mind that in the book, in the battle fought just outside the...
On the Matter of Trolls
Posted by The Light of Earendil on 02-18-03
The trolls were on the black gates opening the doors in the movie and...
Re: Successors
Posted by Joe T. on 02-18-03
Having been reading the Christopher Tolkien books and I, for one, would...
Re: Scouring of the Shire
Posted by Aredhel on 02-18-03
I've heard that the Scouring of the Shire (one of the bestest parts of...
|
