|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 No Spoiler Review
Posted by Magic Fire on 12-18-03
Well, by now many of you have seen The Return of the King. The movie, as far as I was concerned, was spectacular. The only thing that I wish was...
I Saw It!!!!
Posted by Earendil 91 on 12-20-03
I saw the Rotk yesterday and it blew me away! Shelob, the Oliphaunts, ghosts you name it. I was a bit disappointed in Frodo and Sam though.
Book & Movie Reality
Posted by jopo on 12-20-03
Ya know, I'm reading so many comments about how Jackson didn't stick to the story line, and how Jackson changed this, and how Jackson omitted...
Return of the King Mistakes?
Posted by Nat on 12-20-03
I just saw the return of the King yesterday and I have to say it was extremley good.I would have loved to have seen Saruman and the Scouring of the...
Repsonses Galore
Posted by Lem on 12-20-03
smack: Not only did the beginning sequence of the movie give andy serkis face time, but it helped explain how gollum got to be the way he is for all...
Dear Lilly
Posted by Pippin on 12-20-03
To Lilly: I am really sorry about your friends making fun of the movie. There was a goup of teenagers in front of the theater moking the movie it...
Pippin's Song
Posted by Pippin on 12-20-03
Does anyone know the lyrics to Pippin's song that he sang? It was really sad and I would really like to learn...
Another Review
Posted by Pip on 12-20-03
Hey peoples! The hobbit correspondent is back with his review, so if you haven't seen the movie yet, open this article and then cover your...
To Lannor
Posted by Louimir on 12-20-03
You're joking, right? Read the late professor's letters before you make any claim LOTR is not a "Christian" story. You sound pretty much like...
All Hail Peter Jackson
Posted by G on 12-21-03
SPOILERS!!! That was one good movie. 'd love to have seen Saruman again or a little more of Merry and Pippin at Isengard and the houses...
Forgot Something
Posted by G on 12-21-03
I've just remembered a continuity error I noticed in RotK. In Two Towers Extended we saw Merry and Pippin drink the Entdraught and grow taller but...
RotK... Fell Flat for Me
Posted by steve on 12-21-03
Well I have just seen ROTK and I have to say I was very disappointed. There was far too much deviation from the book for me. Things were said and...
Westu Peter Jackson Hál!
Posted by Lady of Rohan on 12-21-03
Wow, now that I've actually sat down to write this, words fail me. ROTK was definitely the best of the three movies. There were a few extremely...
A Requiem for What Might Have Been
Posted by jaws on 12-21-03
I have had 2 days to consider The Movie and I don't know whether I should celebrate the movie that was or mourn the movie that could have been.
At Long Last, After Three Years...
Posted by Bob Praz on 12-21-03
I have finally seen it. Thus, inevitably, I have much to say. Although first I’ll just say that ROTK did not disappoint. Alright, here I go...
I Feel Your Pain Lilly!
Posted by Ashleigh on 12-21-03
To Lilly: I can thoroughly say I understand what you went through. I saw the movie with one of my friends, who was not the most appreciating of the...
RotK Rocks!!! Spoilers Ahead!
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 12-21-03
First off this will probably be kind of lengthy and for those who dont mind you can go ahead and read away!!!! It is now 3:30 in the morning and...
My Last LotR Review
Posted by Jafo on 12-23-03
Definite spoilers in this article! Well, every year for the last three years I have submitted my review of the current LOTR release. This I guess...
Here We Go Again...
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 12-23-03
Must we start over again with the stupid religion/Christianity thing? The most wonderful movie of all time just came out (I haven't seen it yet...
RotK Deleted Scenes?
Posted by chris on 12-23-03
After seeing ROTK, i can safley say it was one of the best movies i have ever seen. The changes put in did more to add then to detract to the movie.
Tolkien Fans
Posted by smack on 12-23-03
I know that they must make the film for all others who haven’t read the books, but think that satisfying 1 Tolkien fan is equal to satisfying 200...
Tolkien, C.S. Lewis and Religion
Posted by Orangeblossom on 12-23-03
I really do not think it does not matter whether or not Lord of the Rings is Christian or not. I mean I did not get that C.S. Lewis's Naria was...
Pippin's Song
Posted by Lilly on 12-23-03
Funny thing: this super-sad song features the lyrics of a condensed version of the cheerful, bouncing walking song that the hobbits sing in the FOTR...
A Red Sun Rises
Posted by jazz_man on 12-23-03
Hello again my friends. Well I cant remember who asked, but some time ago someone asked a question refering to Legolas line in the TTT movie, about...
Pippin's Song
Posted by Baggins on 12-23-03
Home is behind. The world is ahead. And there are may paths to tread. Thru the shadow to the edge of night. Until the stars are all alight. Mist and...
Great Movie!
Posted by Idril on 12-24-03
I can sympathize with Lilly! I saw the movie twice and both times.....well let's just say I will go see it by myself in the middle of day the third...
Re: Fell Flat, and Other Stuff
Posted by Danny on 12-24-03
If your grievances with ROTK are that it deviated from the books than how can you honestly say that Two Towers is the best film in the trilogy or...
The Purist Review (many Spoilers)
Posted by Everett on 12-24-03
Well, I saw RotK twice within its first 24 hours in the theater: the first midnight showing, and one at 7:45 PM, and now that RotK is in the...
More on RotK
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 12-24-03
First off I would like to aggree with Lady of Rohan and say that if ROTK doesn't get nominated in any of the catagories that really matter that I...
A Question
Posted by Magic Fire on 12-24-03
Over the course of the release of the three movies, every once in a while I would read a fan comment or a review saying that Elijah Wood is too...
...but Where Was That?
Posted by Lilly on 12-24-03
Looking back at early ROTK trailers, I wonder about a few things I saw there but not in the movie, and which I hope to see in the EE DVD...
The King Returneth
Posted by Annatar on 12-24-03
The Return Of The King, I've seen it twice so far (there will be many more) and I gotta say that it does get better with repeated viewing.
The Age of the Fellowship
Posted by Pippin on 12-24-03
Ok... I dont want to sound stuped but can somebody smart please tell me the age of each member of the fellowship at the begining of the trilogy and...
Wow, Steve, Wow
Posted by Incanus on 12-26-03
Hi steve, how ya doin? I am very inquisitive and am just wondering how, in your mind, ROTK ventured so far from the books and what things in...
Re: Jafo's Review
Posted by Magic Fire on 12-26-03
I read you review and just thought I should tell you that there was indeed mention in ROTK of Smeagol's birthday by Smeagol himself, just like in...
The Shire
Posted by Orangeblossom on 12-26-03
I am reading the Scouring of the Shire chapter, and I somewhat miss seeing it in the movie. the growth of the Pippin, Merry, and Sam is very nice...
Elves at Helms Deep and Wow
Posted by Elanor on 12-26-03
Orangeblossom, I'm not exactly sure, but I think all the elves were killed at helms deep because remember when they are bolting the last door...
Um...eioul?
Posted by Elanor on 12-26-03
I'm kinda confused by what you wrote. You said that the books were of course Christian, yet then you pretty much dissed Chrissy who had said...
Skull Head
Posted by p-money on 12-26-03
sup ma homies if any of you guys have or can score sum or a picture of the orc general with the little skull on his head that yells out catapults in...
It Is a Sad Sad Day When...
Posted by Annatar on 12-26-03
It is indeed a sad sad day when allies cannot disagree with each other with out it degrading into a insult frenzy. What am I talking about?!?
Prequel - The Hobbit
Posted by Sherpa on 12-26-03
So what are the chances that they’ll do The Hobbit now? I really think they should. Do it now before the actors they need to reuse from LOTR age to...
The Big Disappointment
Posted by Melkor on 12-27-03
Well I was there, opening night at 12:01 for the very first screening of ROTK. The anticipation was amazing, the theatre full, everyone waiting to...
About Wood
Posted by Pippin on 12-27-03
To Magic Fire I think Elijah Wood was perfect for the part. Elijah is a good acter who... in my opinion filled the part of Frodo perfectly.
RotK EE: Extended Scenes (very Long List)
Posted by Bob Praz on 12-27-03
Ok, since we're sort of on the subject, with all the discussions of scenes that were cut from ROTK, I've made a list of all the possible extended...
To Everett
Posted by Lem on 12-27-03
I see your points, Everett...and i agree. I didn't notice so many things when I was watching, I was so wrapped up in it....but your criticisms make...
The End of All Things (some Wee Spoilers)
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 12-27-03
Greetings all. I've seen the Return of the King twice now and I can only say. "Wow!" It is unbelieveable. As a film, it is the best I have...
Oscars
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 12-27-03
On the subject of Oscar nominations I have some ideas. Best Actor: Elijah Wood. His performence as Frodo was taken to a whole new level in ROTK.
Frodo's Scars
Posted by Wilwarin on 12-27-03
When Frodo was taken captive and relieved of all his equipment at Cirith Ungol, we see 2 scars on his chest. One I know is from Weathertop, but I am...
Frodo's Age
Posted by Elanor on 12-27-03
Well, I'd like to say something about Frodo's age. I think it was Magic Fire who said it was done correctly. I agree. And also, I mean, seriously...
Rock on RotK!
Posted by Imlar on 12-28-03
Just a no-brainer article to state my appreciation of PJ's latest masterpiece. This was my favourite book, and the standards were high!
|
