|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Re: Question
Posted by Danny on 05-22-03
I beleive Gandalf knew that he was not as powerful as Sauron...
Re: Year of Lamentation
Posted by G on 05-22-03
(Warning : Silmarillion spoilers) Viking, you are correct, the Year...
Response to Lilly
Posted by Paths_of_the_dead on 05-22-03
In response to Lilly's question: my indulgence in the Lord of the Rings...
This and That
Posted by Lilly on 05-22-03
First off, in response to G, what I meant when I said "I'll only have to...
Something Old, Something New
Posted by Lilly on 05-22-03
Mr. Underhill, I did hear that there would be many more Ent scenes...
Gollum in Khazad-dum
Posted by Entwash on 05-22-03
I think the best explanation of how Gollum got past the Bridge...
A Happy Day
Posted by Lilly on 05-23-03
Today (the 21st) is my birthday. It started out as a pleasant one...
Response to Andrew
Posted by Lilly on 05-23-03
Andrew, they won't leave out Pippin's encounter with the Palantir...
Merry and Pippin's Moments to Shine
Posted by Lilly on 05-23-03
In the books, the hobbits Pippin and Merry really don't do a whole lot...
To Tiniowien
Posted by Paths_of_the_dead on 05-23-03
Tiniowien, I too thoroughly enjoy the Narnia series, but I find...
Reponse to Knotwise
Posted by Lilly on 05-23-03
All that you said about music was good... I hadn't notice all that before...
Whoops! (Possibly)
Posted by Lilly on 05-23-03
If you dislike being confused, don't read this. In one of my other...
Confusion....confusion!
Posted by Lilly on 05-24-03
I honestly thought I understood the books, but now I wonder if I've not...
Narnia
Posted by Lilly on 05-24-03
The Narnia books are wonderful, but did you know that Tolkien...
Saruman Speculation
Posted by G on 05-24-03
As far as I am concerned, there is little doubt that Saruman's death in...
Re: Paths_of_the_dead
Posted by Tiniowien on 05-24-03
Let me explain my opinion of the last Narnia book a bit more thouroughly...
The Witch King vs the Mouth of Sauron
Posted by Niphredil on 05-24-03
Danny, an interesting question. Who was more powerful? Both of them...
Response to Lilly and Niphredil
Posted by G on 05-26-03
Lilly, Niphredil has already answered this but I thougt I'd say my piece...
Witchking vs. Mouth of Sauron
Posted by Loremaster on 05-26-03
I whould have to agree totally with Niphredil on that the Witch King...
Back at Tiniowien
Posted by Paths_of_the_dead on 05-26-03
Okay, I wasn't sure if you were aware of Lewis's Christian background.
Response to G
Posted by Lilly on 05-26-03
It is almost certain that Wormtoungue kills Saruman, and that he does...
RotK Ending
Posted by Danny on 05-26-03
I have heard through a very unreliable source, though that unreliable...
Witch King or Mouth of Sauron
Posted by Danny on 05-26-03
I agree with your ideas about the Witch King being more powerful...
'Ring-vision'
Posted by Amy on 05-27-03
Why does Frodo see things so strangly while wearing the Ring...
Re: Saruman Speculation
Posted by Niphredil on 05-27-03
G, I agree with you, that it is very likely that Wormtongue will kill...
Response to Lilly
Posted by Andrew on 05-27-03
Yes, Lilly, the Witch King is the Head Ringwraith. Eowyn killed the...
Odds and Ends
Posted by G on 05-27-03
OK, I have a couple of thins to say here and it would probably be wise...
Anicipation (warning: Story Spoilers)
Posted by Lilly on 05-27-03
As a HUGE Sam and Frodo fan, it makes sense that the scenes...
Peace...
Posted by Annatar on 05-27-03
Lily, we are never going to agree on a certain matter, so lets just shake...
For Lilly, the Grey Havens and Valinor
Posted by Niphredil on 05-28-03
Lilly, the Grey Havens (Mithlond in Sindarin) is the name of the Elvish...
Speaking of Valinor... Why Does Arwen Die?
Posted by Niphredil on 05-28-03
Do you think Arwen was not able to sail West because she...
The Grey Havens
Posted by Manofwesternesse on 05-28-03
Lily, the Grey Havens are not Valinor, nor are they a stop on the way...
Odds & Ends
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 05-28-03
Hey Amy, as to your question about Frodo's "Ring Vision," I think...
Re: Ring-vision
Posted by Fluidshaggy on 05-28-03
Amy, as I myself am currently rereading the hobbit I understand your...
On 'Lothlorien' and the Ringwraiths
Posted by Knotwise on 05-28-03
Many points of business! Argh! 1st - Does anyone know the lyrics that...
Re: Lilly's Anticipation
Posted by Speedcorn on 05-29-03
Lilly, you mentioned the "yet-unheard Gondor theme" in your...
Response to Niphredil
Posted by Tomas on 05-29-03
I think the reason for the mortality of Arwen may be found in the...
Comments on Several Topics
Posted by Jarrickon Falconn on 05-29-03
Elen sila lumenn' omentielvo! This is my first post on this board...
Fallen Valar
Posted by Annatar on 05-29-03
Niphredil, it's just my opinion but Arwen could not go into the west...
Music for Sam and the 'Dead' Frodo
Posted by Knotwise on 05-29-03
Hmm... it seems as if I can't type! I would like to make amends...
Lament for Gandalf
Posted by Wilwarin on 05-29-03
Lament for Gandalf Solo: In gwidh ristennin, i fae narchannen I lach...
Response to Annatar and Everyone
Posted by Lilly on 05-30-03
First: yes, Annatar, let's agree to disagree, but there is something...
Arwen’s Mortality
Posted by Niphredil on 05-30-03
Tomas, and Annatar, thanks for your views. An interesting statement...
Every Race in the Battle of the Last Alliance
Posted by Niphredil on 05-30-03
G, I thought the same as you when I first read the passage. I also find...
The Island Continent of Aman
Posted by Niphredil on 05-30-03
Jarrickon Falconn, I think you will find that Aman was referred to as...
Sibling Trouble
Posted by G on 05-30-03
I have a brother who knows very little about Tolkien. He does, however...
More Arwen & Undying Lands Talk
Posted by Lilly on 05-30-03
I don't think Aragorn and Arwen's children got to choose between...
Gimli Going to Valinor
Posted by G on 05-31-03
Lilly, the reason Gimli was allowed to travel West to Valinor is that...
An Interesting Find...
Posted by Piper on 05-31-03
Interesting find in the Michel Delving Mathom-house! (Otherwise known as...
Forging a New Ruling Ring
Posted by Niphredil on 05-31-03
G, an explanation of why Sauron could not forge another One Ring may...
|
