|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Movie Portrayal vs Book
Posted by Sara on 03-05-03
I just stumbled onto this site this morning, and found alot of very...
The Heroism of Frodo
Posted by Dwian on 03-05-03
Frodo is the undisputable hero of the Lord of the Rings and this is why...
Re: Justin, How to End RotK
Posted by Colin on 03-07-03
In relation to speculation about how ROTK might end, this might prove...
Enough Already
Posted by J. Bruce on 03-07-03
I've been reading the posts on this website for a year or so now and...
Re: Copewilson
Posted by Danny on 03-07-03
I understand people's frustrations with adaptations from the film...
In Response to Copewilson
Posted by Derek Bessette on 03-07-03
Inasmuch as this dialogue has been going on for years, since the...
Book to Movie
Posted by Amy on 03-07-03
Let's remember that most movies (any?) are longer than three hours...
Re: Why Change?
Posted by Honeymonster on 03-07-03
Poor Faramir, but Sara (of 03-02-03 fame), I think I know the reason...
Answers for Thorden
Posted by Matt Mcnabb on 03-10-03
Before the beginning of the First Age the Elves first awoke at Cuivienen.
Re: There Were Only Two Elves at Helms Deep
Posted by Theoda of Westfold on 03-10-03
Actually Dee, Legolas was the only elf at Helms Deep, as Elladan and...
Response to C. on Glorfindel
Posted by Peter D. on 03-10-03
I agree with you that Glorfindel from the books would have been an cool...
Therese, I Couldn't Have Put It Better Myself!
Posted by Kimmy on 03-10-03
I first saw LoTR when my family and I rented it about a year ago...
Where is Arwen Going?
Posted by Happiscotsman on 03-10-03
Just a little base assumption with no data to back it up...
Glorfindel
Posted by Dominic on 03-10-03
Just a quick note on Glorfindel. The one who lives at Rivendell is not...
Response to Tom on Arwen
Posted by Moraelyn on 03-11-03
When Arwen says that she chooses a mortal life it doesn't actually...
Non-blemishes
Posted by Curious George on 03-11-03
You have to admit that there were some great elements in TTT...
Way to Word It Lady O Rohan!
Posted by Pip on 03-11-03
Yes, it is I, Pip! Here I am back again after my long hiatus from this...
Middle Earth, History, and Current Events
Posted by Jim Cooper on 03-11-03
Dusty 103 asks of the BBC, do these people not read the news...
Tolkien's Goal
Posted by Ray Shreckengost on 03-11-03
I have just read two recent posts on this website. One deals with the...
Re: Frodo's Heroism
Posted by Danny on 03-11-03
There is a moment right before the one you mentioned where the ring...
To Dusty103
Posted by Michaeltolliver on 03-12-03
Dusty, you say we should know the truth, and learn the truth. I say you...
Frodo and the Nazgul
Posted by Viking on 03-12-03
When I first saw the Two Towers I was, like many, stunned by some...
Hobbit Teaser Trailer Comment
Posted by Brad Cook on 03-12-03
I really enjoyed the Hobbit teaser trailer that was cleverly put...
Reply to the Happyscotsman on Arwen
Posted by Peter D. on 03-12-03
Of course none of us (except for PJ and the rest of the initiated) really...
Diversity
Posted by Mithril Miner on 03-12-03
I have seen several posts on this sight concerning diversity in...
Response to Moraelyn
Posted by Yavanna on 03-12-03
In response to Moraelyn's point that Arwen went to Lorien, then...
Response to Moraelyn and Tom on Arwen
Posted by Undomiel on 03-13-03
"But Arwen went forth from the House, and the light of her eyes was...
Lets Keep Politics Out of the Forum
Posted by Magic Fire on 03-13-03
This response is do to the several comparisons that are being made...
Re: Michaeltolliver
Posted by Stephen Faherty on 03-14-03
You interpetation of recent history is quit amusing. Which country...
The United States is Minis Tirith Not Mordor
Posted by John Ward on 03-14-03
I have read the foolish and unfortunate comparisons many of you...
Mordor Ready to Go It Alone for Peace
Posted by Sam Ford on 03-14-03
Text of Lord Sauron’s speech as reported in “The Morgul News”...
The Doom of Arwen
Posted by Tomas on 03-14-03
The matter concerning the mortality of Arwen may be found in the book...
About Brego
Posted by Nattie on 03-14-03
Where did Brego come from? In the book, the rangers come and give...
Yes, Keep Politics Out of Lotr!
Posted by Amy on 03-15-03
I remember reading somewhere that Tolkien was questioned whether his...
About Brego
Posted by Pip on 03-15-03
I believe that Brego (in the movie of course, don't any of you Tolkien...
Tolkien is Rolling in His Grave
Posted by Ordinary Turtle on 03-15-03
I wouldn't be surprised if Tolkien was rolling in his grave right now...
Brego Even Strange Than That
Posted by Chambers on 03-15-03
This is in response the question about Aragorn's horse Brego in the...
The Account of Isildur
Posted by Andrew on 03-15-03
In the first movie, when Gandalf goes to Minas Tirith and reads the...
Everyone Defending America - Thanks
Posted by Deidra on 03-15-03
I would just like to commend all of the people defending America...
It is Not Saruman We Should Fear, But Denethor
Posted by Brett C. on 03-16-03
I have just finished reading some fairly inflamatory articles regarding...
Re: The United States is Minis Tirith Not Mordor
Posted by Aragorn on 03-16-03
Go tell the people of Vietnam, Irak, Afghanistan and Iran, places were...
Wild Men and the Harad People
Posted by Grub on 03-16-03
I was wondering about something in the third book and I decided to post.
Brego
Posted by Danny on 03-16-03
I may be wrong, but I remember Brego being the horse that Eomer...
Brego Again
Posted by Eonwe on 03-16-03
I think I heard somewhere, once that Brego was origionally the horse...
Re: Isuldur's Scroll
Posted by Brett C. on 03-16-03
Andrew, the answer to your question is that PJ and co opted to...
Things Still to Come
Posted by Brett C. on 03-17-03
I was recently fliping through some magazine or book covering info...
Brego
Posted by Brett C. on 03-17-03
Sorry Pip, the horses Eomer gives the Three Hunters in the movie...
Sauron = George Bush (to Diedra)
Posted by Radagast the Brown on 03-17-03
America the only country to go to the lands of out enemies? You are the...
Read If Your Posts Aren't Appearing
Posted by Matthew on 03-17-03
This is yet another reminder to all of those who post to the debate...
Response to Brett C. on Deleted Scenes
Posted by Peter D. on 03-18-03
There was/is actually another version shot of the fellowships entry into...
|
