|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Re: Blue Sky in Mordor
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 11-07-03
You know, I was wondering about that, too. Morodor's supposed to be this place of darkness and terror and yet we see this bright blue sky!
Sunshine in Mordor? Don't Worry...
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-07-03
I've seen this question asked before, but I can't recall if I actually answered. Anyhow, the most likely reason why we see a lot of these early pictures of the movie...
New Thoughts
Posted by Orangeblossom on 11-07-03
I came home from exercising and my brothers mobbed me. They went to buy a new hero click, and hero clicks are coming out with Lord of the Rings hero clicks.
Man, I Don't Know What to Say About This...
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-08-03
I don't know how many of you have read the news from AICN lately (also posted on TORn), but if not, than here's a big (and probably disappointing) spoiler...
Ack...ack...ack...ack!
Posted by Imlar on 11-08-03
Ack! (Yes, I know I already stated this) but I'm shocked. I was chatting with my friend Bob Praz on the Internet and he pointed me to the article on theonering.net about...
General Audiences Will Be Cheated
Posted by Joel on 11-08-03
I never thought I would register, despite reading the posts frequently but after reading some disturbing news from theonering.net and seeing no posts directed upon it I had to voice an opinion that I know few will disagree with.
I Agree
Posted by Orangeblossom on 11-08-03
To cut Saruman out of the movie is an awful move. It would destroy the intergrity of the movie.
Saruman's Out?????
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 11-09-03
I cannot believe they would take Saruman and Grima out of ROTK!!!!!!!
I'm Out of It for a While...
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 11-09-03
And look what happens.
I must confess that my last article was written without looking at any Tolkien News whatsoever.
No Saruman
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 11-09-03
Ok, I will try to be calm but it's probably not going to happen!!!!!!!!!!
What The?
Posted by Tuor on 11-09-03
I finally have time out of school to read the forum and this is what I have to read? I'm sorry but I'm not as patient as Bob Praz.
Saruman's Omission
Posted by Fallongirl5150 on 11-10-03
Yeah, I disagree with the decision to cut out Saruman (and the Scouring of the Shire, but that's another argument for another day) but in no way do I consider him a "sell out".
Noooooooooo
Posted by Foxy on 11-10-03
AHHHHHHHHHHHHH! I can't believe this is happening! cutting that scene is horrible!
RotK Music
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 11-10-03
Yesturday I was very very very very very (well you get my drift) upset about this whole Saruman and Grima thing.
New Desktop
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 11-10-03
I know I know, I just sent in something but I just found out somethin. LOTR.net just put up some new desktop images of EE of TTT.
Well...
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 11-10-03
Okay, I know that I'm probably going to be e-murdered for this, but....
Maybe we're all blowing this whole "Saruman out of ROTK" thing a little out of proportion?
I Am New But I Agree
Posted by Earendil 91 on 11-10-03
It is stupid that pj isn't putting in the sauruman/wormtongue part.
Rubble? No
Posted by Pip on 11-11-03
Wait a minute... Pip refuses to find the Palantir among the rubble. Pip insists on having the giant marble flung at him.
News About Saruman
Posted by Magic Fire on 11-11-03
For all you people who are upset about the Saruman/Grima scene being left out of the Return of the King, you can always sign the petition...
Saruman Out!!! Big Mistake
Posted by Danny on 11-11-03
Gandalf's confrontation with Saruman is important in a lot of ways. It demonstrates Gandalf's growth in status and power as Gandalf the White...
RotK Extended DVD, EA Game, RotK Soundtrack, etc.
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-12-03
Ok, first, about the Saruman's scene in ROTK that has been cut out (over which we have all been seemingly very passionate)...
I Agree Danny
Posted by Samwise on 11-12-03
Your article was well written and i agree with all your ideas. I too have the ROTK game and it is much better than the TTT game they made last year.
Things Unclear in TTT
Posted by Muppet on 11-12-03
Hello nerds, Now I'm sure all of what I say has been discussed before but I'd like to say them anyway...
Re: Things Unclear
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 11-13-03
No, Celeborn doesn't bring the Elves to Helm's Deep, that elf is Haldir.
Okay, Okay...[a Couple Things]
Posted by Lilly on 11-13-03
first off: I agree: I'll really miss that whole Saruman/Wormtounge sequence, BUT I don't think it's the worst thing that could have happened.
Muppet's Questions and Saruman Issue
Posted by David on 11-13-03
Haldir clarification...
Hmmm…methinks you missed the section in both the theatrical and extended Fellowship where we meet Haldir.
Overreaction; Unclear
Posted by Tuor on 11-13-03
All right, maybe I am overreacting slightly. Technically, PJ can't be a sellout if he is still including Saruman in the EE.
Amateurs and Film Makers
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 11-13-03
First of all, I would like to commend Bob Praz for his highly logical and well-written article about the elimination of Saruman in the Theatrical cut.
Things All Cleared Up (or Mostly)
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 11-13-03
That was Haldir who brought the Lothlorien elves to Helm's Deep. If you'll remember he was also the one in the book and movie who meets/confronts the Fellowship in FOTR.
Frodo's Dreams and Fell Beasts
Posted by Brett C. on 11-14-03
Hello all. Been away for a while.
Lilly, Frodo has several semi-prophetic dreams throughout the course of the novel, a fact which is paid homeage to by PJ at the start of TTT...
Things I'm Not Sorry Didn't Make It In...
Posted by Lilly on 11-14-03
Lately we've been lamenting all the book-things left out of the movies...but I've a couple things I'm GLAD I'll never see stuck into the movies...
Answers to Some Questions
Posted by Earendil 91 on 11-15-03
Some answers to the questions from the dude with the numbers.
Re: Brett C and Fell Beasts
Posted by Magic Fire on 11-15-03
Hello again to all and especially Brett C: I agree completely with you on the anatomy of the "fell beasts".
PJ is Doing Great
Posted by Eric the Brown on 11-15-03
Hello all this is my first post although I have enjoyed following the forum since the movies have come out.
Alot of Stuff to Cover! So Sit Tight.
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 11-15-03
Ah!!! The weekend is finally here!!!! I have time to look at posts etc...
Elves at Helm's Deep and Gorbag/Shagrat in RotK
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-16-03
I don't know where, but somewhere I read (or heard, maybe) that there were 150 elves at Helm's Deep, according to Richard Taylor, I believe.
I Do Not Have a DVD Player
Posted by Orangeblossom on 11-16-03
With regards I do not have a DVD player, so the fact that the confrontation will be in the Extend Version is not much of a confort.
Glad PJ Left Out Bombadil
Posted by Tuor on 11-16-03
Well, I'm glad that PJ left out Bombadil as well. If anything, that would just confuse people even more because he just twiddles the ring on his finger like it's nothing in the books.
Tidbits
Posted by Imlar on 11-16-03
Well, about what I'm happy PJ didn't keep in the film, I agree with most of what has been said already.
Re: No DVD Player
Posted by Lilly on 11-16-03
IT'S OKAY IF YOU HAVEN'T GOT A DVD PLAYER: I've said it before, but I don't mind repeating myself.
Frodo's Mithril Coat and Other Things
Posted by Danny on 11-16-03
In my mind,it is almost a guarantee that someone will bring Frodo's coat to Sauron. There is a clip that has shown up in some trailers that is very very short...
Quick Corrections!!!
Posted by Imlar on 11-17-03
Sorry guys, just that in my last article I wrote a messed up statement because I forgot one very important word...
Mithril Coat and Mordor Uruk-hai
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-17-03
In response to Danny, I think I'm reassured now that PJ will somehow incorporate Frodo's mithril coat in the movie...
!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by Wilwarin on 11-17-03
ONE MONTH GUYS, ONE MONTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WOO HOO WOO HOO...
Bombadil and Entmoot
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 11-17-03
I'm glad that Bombadil was left out of the movie. While I still think that it would be cool to see that part, it just wouldn't fit with the rest of the movie...
Tom
Posted by Orangeblossom on 11-18-03
I did not know about the VHS, thank you Lilly. My teacher of my class in which we studied Lord of the Rings had an interesting idea about Tom.
Tom Bombadil
Posted by Strider on 11-18-03
Hello all. I've been away for some time, but know I'm back in hopes to answer all of your quesions.
TTT EE! Got It at Last!
Posted by Bob Praz on 11-19-03
Ok, as quickly as possible I will say what I have to say, as I have little time at the moment.
I haven't watched the extended movie yet, because I once again have no time on school nights...
Okay, Who Was Lying?
Posted by Pip on 11-19-03
Pip has just watched the deleted scenes in the EE of TTT, and found absolutely NO Saruman death scene. What happened?!?!
Two Towers EE
Posted by Magic Fire on 11-19-03
Well, I assume that most of you have now seen the Two Towers EE and if you haven't, that you are planning to in the next few days.
|
