|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Response to Brett C.
Posted by Matt Mcnabb on 02-18-03
Brett, you're right on several points. The part with Frodo is in...
Various Subjects
Posted by Lady of Rohan on 02-18-03
After reading several recently posted articles (especially's Brett C.'s...
Re: The Question of Faramir
Posted by Jocelyn on 02-19-03
I've pondered Faramir and the reasons his character seemed so...
Two Things About TTT
Posted by Derin Lorecryer on 02-19-03
Two Things: First of all: Yes! For the final time the...
Re: Whether Another Author Should Pick Up
Posted by Brendan Cooke on 02-19-03
I remember reading that Tolkien's idea was to create a mythology for...
Frodo in Scouring the Shire
Posted by Copans on 02-19-03
I'd like to add a note to Everett on the Scouring of the Shire. It's...
A Little Lost and Confused...
Posted by Aemilia on 02-19-03
Okay, this has nothing to do with either of the movies, which is what...
The 'Racist' Issue
Posted by Elf Girl on 02-19-03
I recently read an article about the 'racism' issue that has been...
Haldir
Posted by Ingvanye on 02-21-03
I just wanted to say that the Elves arriving at Helms Deep was a...
The Scourge and the Havens
Posted by A. Gordon on 02-21-03
It seems to me that the movie has been a little weak with Frodo's...
The Two Movies So Far
Posted by Regina on 02-21-03
FotR: The thing about the first movie that really jarred with me was the...
How to End Trotk...
Posted by Justin on 02-21-03
After seeing TTT I couldn't help myself from imagining what's to come.
Faramir Was Alright
Posted by Tomas on 02-21-03
When I saw TTT the first time I was upset as you all of how different the...
Response to Daniel: More Deleted Scenes
Posted by Andrew on 02-21-03
Yes, daniel, I believe that that line of Gandalf's to Aragorn will be...
To Much Change
Posted by Firniswin on 02-25-03
Hello, I would like to start by saying that I liked TTT but it was far...
Jackson's Cameo
Posted by Spyros 'olorin' Vris on 02-25-03
I don't know if anyone has mentioned that yet, but I believe that I've...
Silence From PJ?
Posted by Radagast the White on 02-25-03
Is any official comment known from Peter Jackson or associates on the...
Elmo--you Are Exactly Right, and That's the Prob
Posted by Copewilson on 02-25-03
Elmo has put his finger superbly on the problem of Jackson...
On Two Towers and Return of the King
Posted by Andrew on 02-25-03
First of all, alot of people are saying that they think Return of the...
The Movies
Posted by Rebecca Johnson on 02-25-03
This is just a comment on the making of the LOTR movies. 30 years...
Two Towers and Other Mistakes
Posted by Firniswin on 02-25-03
ok I donot have lot of time but I would like to say that PJ could have...
Faramir
Posted by Jadehunter on 02-25-03
I liked the movie Faramir. Someone on the regular message boards...
Two Towers 'Changes'
Posted by Magic Fire on 02-27-03
There has been so much written about the deviations from the book...
On Oral Tradition and Religion
Posted by Everett on 02-27-03
Over the past few days, people have been making two points to justify...
Elves at Helms Deep
Posted by Vigorous More-tension on 02-27-03
First the dumb question: why does the Balrog have wings if it cannot...
Re: It's Soooo Easy, Among Other Things
Posted by Everett on 02-27-03
Francois, your criticisms of our criticisms of the movie seem to be...
Technical Comments on TTT
Posted by Eric K. on 02-27-03
A lot of well-written comments about the deviations of the movies from...
Location of Himring, Thangorodrim
Posted by Annatar on 02-27-03
Perhaps I imagined it but did Tolkien once say he based Middle-Earth...
Shoulda Known
Posted by Iklarsis on 03-02-03
I knew that if anyone were to ever make these films, that there would be...
There Were Only 2 Elfs at Helm's Deep
Posted by Dee on 03-02-03
I sat down after watching TTT three times, pondering what it was...
Response to Judy Ann
Posted by Ashleigh F. on 03-02-03
Yes, I do support most of your ideas, Judy Ann, but one, your first idea...
Ending of the Third Book?
Posted by Thorden on 03-02-03
Hi all - just discovered this board. Please forgive me if this is covered...
Various Things
Posted by E. Blair on 03-02-03
In response to various postings: I know the book and the movie are...
Why Change?
Posted by Sara on 03-02-03
King Theoden possessed by Saruman? That wasn't in the book...
The Enemy of Good
Posted by Straightarrow on 03-03-03
The enemy of good is "a little better". I remember taking...
Response to Andrew on Arwen
Posted by Tom M. on 03-03-03
When Arwen says that she'll "choose a mortal life" she means...
Response to Andrew
Posted by Mithril Miner on 03-03-03
Dear Andrew: I have to disagree with your comment on the Treebeard...
Finally Two Views Presented
Posted by Danny on 03-03-03
I am releived to see that people are posting both sides of criticism for...
Opinion of a Newcomer
Posted by Therese on 03-03-03
Opinion of a newcomer: I had never read The Lord of the Rings. I’m not...
Glorfindel
Posted by C on 03-03-03
This is just an observation, not an attack on PJ's portrayal of LOTR...
TTT is Trash, What of RotK?
Posted by Brad Cook on 03-04-03
A posting of this type maybe a little late but... Maybe I am more of a...
The RotK Advances
Posted by Ecthelion on 03-04-03
I have been told by many sources that the ROTK movie is going to...
Anduril's Absence
Posted by Ray Shreckengost on 03-04-03
I was checking out this website today, and I noticed something that...
Reply to Comments and Explanations
Posted by Monica on 03-04-03
In Comments and Explanations you mentioned the belief that Morgoth...
In Response to Elf Girl
Posted by Lady of Rohan on 03-04-03
Elf Girl, you are right. Tolkien did NOT mean to be racist when he wrote...
About RotK
Posted by Elbereth on 03-04-03
I haven't posted anything here in a long time but this debating over...
Re: The 'Racist' Issue
Posted by Jocelyn on 03-05-03
In response to Elf Girl's question about why weren't there dark-skinned...
Re-release of TTT in March?
Posted by Kalis on 03-05-03
I was watching CNN a few days ago and during one of their Showbiz...
BBC Names Bush 'Servant of Sauron'
Posted by Dusty103 on 03-05-03
I have recently read where President Bush is compared to Sauruman...
The Question of Faramir and Moral Authority
Posted by Alan Rustici on 03-05-03
I was tempted to name this piece “Why Peter Jackson is like the...
|
