|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Response To Danny
Posted by Jimeous on 07-21-02
Quoted... Furthermore about why Sam wouldn't disappear when...
Climbing Into the Ring(s)
Posted by Brett C. on 07-22-02
Thank you for the people who have gotten involved in the discussion...
Fans
Posted by Brett C. on 07-22-02
About 6 months ago I was in a bookshop and of course I was browsing...
Fan Or Not
Posted by Peter D. on 07-22-02
Just a quick comment on the distinction between us die-hard...
Evils of Tolkien Snobbery
Posted by Lady of Rohan on 07-22-02
I suppose this essay is in response to Ray S.'s initial letter of...
Re: Elven Apperance
Posted by Beans on 07-22-02
Felagund, like you I was very impressed by the Elves and the way Peter...
Was Gandalf Foolish? (Response to Annatar)
Posted by David H. on 07-23-02
I wish to respond to Annatar's comment from 7-16 that Gandalf was a...
Gandalf the Wiser
Posted by Danny on 07-23-02
Remember Gandalfs very wise words about Gollum? I don't have a book...
Re: Sauron's Stupidity
Posted by Loremaster on 07-23-02
OK, it is pretty understood that Sauron was more powerful than gandalf,...
My Arwen Problem
Posted by Wulfric on 07-23-02
I don't really have a problem with Arwen taking Glorfindels place or how...
Against Arwen
Posted by Trowie on 07-23-02
In response to Joe's question about why those on this board dislike...
News Just In: Gollum Was Pushed!
Posted by Brett C. on 07-24-02
This is one of those interesting little details in LOTR which leaps out...
Why Visible?
Posted by Annatar on 07-24-02
Brett C, I had to laugh when I read ".. give them a sporting chance"...
Whether You Will Or No
Posted by Brett C. on 07-24-02
There have been several articles about the invisiblity induced by the One...
Will Invisiblity? Nope!
Posted by Annatar on 07-24-02
Everyone seems to think that invisiblity that the ring confers is a...
Response to Jimeous
Posted by Danny on 07-24-02
First off, in the movie, Frodo wasn't wearing the ring so Sam wouldn't...
Concerning Ring Invisibility
Posted by Jeff C. on 07-25-02
To reply to Baldrick and Lily Bumbleroot, there are some other things...
Girdle of Melian
Posted by Fingolfin on 07-25-02
Hey just to change tunes a little in postings, I'd like to bring up one...
Fan Or No Fan?
Posted by Faramir the Brave on 07-25-02
I decided after reading all this junk about people crying over real...
Fuzzy Elves
Posted by Brett C. on 07-25-02
Very quick point. Elves are not necessarily naturally beardless. If you...
Fans
Posted by Laurie on 07-25-02
In repsonse to Ray S.'s post, I'de like to say something. Ok, yes, I...
Ring and Invisibility
Posted by Radagast The Brown on 07-26-02
Some have said that a bearer of the Ring cannot control the Ring's...
Re: Elven Appearance
Posted by Mewlip on 07-26-02
Forget Jackson, here's some Tolkien description ~ Noldor: "This was...
Saurons Invisibility
Posted by Arina on 07-26-02
Brett C. Thankyou for clarifying that for me. Now reading your latest...
Stir the Hornets Nest!
Posted by Annatar on 07-26-02
David H, it was fate that laid out the path to the rings destruction?!
Re: Sauron's Stupidity
Posted by Elbereth on 07-26-02
By Sauron's stupidity i meant in making the ring and putting so much of...
Fans, Continued
Posted by Donna W. on 07-27-02
I really enjoyed Brett C.'s disscussion on the new wave of Tolkien...
Wings, Shadow, and Sails
Posted by Smaug on 07-27-02
This is a belated response to Mewlip's article on Balrog wings. He...
Dual Response to Anatar
Posted by Danny on 07-27-02
Hey I am glad to see that you agree with me over the ring invisibility...
What a Coincedence
Posted by Brett C. on 07-27-02
It would seem, Annatar, that either great minds really do think alike, or...
Kalimac the Green
Posted by More Invisibility on 07-27-02
Sauron isn't invisible when he wears the ring, right? And yet, Gollum...
Nice Danny...
Posted by Jimeous on 07-30-02
The examples you give are very good :)
Smeagol is in a position of...
Oh I Forgot This Letter...
Posted by Jimeous on 07-30-02
"Sauron sent at once the Ringwraiths. They were naturally fully...
Concerning LotR and Christianity
Posted by Legolas on 07-30-02
I was reading all the discussions on the relation between Lotr and...
In Defense of Arwen
Posted by Legolas on 07-30-02
Even though Arwen did not take Frodo to the Ford in the book, I think...
In Support of Fuzzy Elves
Posted by Dave M. on 07-30-02
Just a quick note in support of Elven beards.
There is a painting by...
Cirdan's Age
Posted by Fingolfin on 07-31-02
After reading some posts I have noticed that some people beleive Cirdan...
Re: Jeff C About Gollum and Ring
Posted by Danny on 07-31-02
Hmmmm good point about the inconsistency with Gollum and the ring...
I Change My Mind About True Fans
Posted by Smee and Smo on 07-31-02
I have good news and bad news(sort of). Good news: I got posted after...
Re: Stir the Hornets Nest
Posted by Elbereth on 07-31-02
Annatar, I disagree with you when you said that Gandalf did not care...
Re: Arina, the Ring, and Sorehead
Posted by Brett C. on 07-31-02
Arina, it does not actually say in the text of LOTR that Sauron...
The Ring
Posted by Annatar on 08-01-02
Elbereth, in one way it could be seen as stupidity, placing so much of...
The Eye of Sauron
Posted by Gorlim the Unhappy on 08-01-02
Hello Tolkien Fans!
Reading Arina's article titled Saurons Invisibility...
Gollum Saw Frodo? To Jeff C.
Posted by Curious George on 08-01-02
Just to clear up a point that Jeff C. brought up. Gollum did not see...
A Fan is a Fan, To Faramir the Brave
Posted by Goldie-Locks on 08-01-02
Faramir the Brave, it seems like you are saying that people who were...
Was Sauon Stupid?
Posted by Dave M. on 08-01-02
I think the answer lies in what Sauron's ultimate motive was. In volume...
Response To 'Stir the Hornet's Nest'
Posted by Peter D. on 08-02-02
Well Annatar, I dont know if you have stirred a hornets nest, but you...
Invisibility, Gollum and Sauron
Posted by Loremaster on 08-02-02
OK, first on the subject of gollum not willing the ring to make him...
Re: Stirring the Hornets Nest
Posted by Danny on 08-02-02
Okay, I am sure that there will be a lot of responses to that statement...
Re: Radagast the Brown
Posted by Danny on 08-02-02
I agree with your statemnt, but felt that your example was flawed. Had...
|
