|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 The Lord of the Rings
Posted by Christian R. on 04-18-02
I have read many books, classics and non-classics, that I have enjoyed...
Weaving, Eagles, Bombadil and Essay
Posted by Diana on 04-19-02
In movies I just see the characters the actors and actresses they play...
Re: Eagles
Posted by Brett C. on 04-19-02
The question about why Frodo couldn't make use of eagles to get to...
Eagles
Posted by Patrick on 04-19-02
Where would the eagles take off from? In the books none of them carry...
Who is Tom Bombadil?
Posted by Quirk on 04-19-02
My first reaction to Tom Bombadil was that he was a sort of incarnate...
Eagles Again
Posted by Renee on 04-20-02
Allright. About my eagle question. I kind of don't think there is an...
About Tom Bombadil
Posted by Johan P. on 04-20-02
I can't sit by without give you my view of Tom Bombadil
I think that...
Re: The Eagles
Posted by Brett C. on 04-20-02
There must be a problem with my computer, since the last couple of...
The Council of Elrond
Posted by Marie C. on 04-20-02
Okay, I was thinking and this came to me. So I must impose another...
Gandalf, the Grey Area
Posted by Curious George on 04-21-02
Someone please tell me, does Gandalf actually die and then come...
Bombadil and Tolkien
Posted by Peter C. on 04-21-02
Whoa, whoa whoa, Quirk. If you've ever read Tolkien's essay "On Fairy...
Good and Evil
Posted by Kailam on 04-21-02
There is one thing in Tolkien's works that, to me, closely mirrors the...
In Answer to Quirk
Posted by Ricahrd P. on 04-21-02
Your point of view about Tolkien's Lord of the Rings showing Deisim is...
Re: Who Is Tom Bombadil?
Posted by Fluidshaggy on 04-22-02
As another person who has only read the Hobbit and LOTR, I can see...
Tolkien's Religious Views: Tom Bombadil
Posted by Olwarz on 04-22-02
This is just a quick commentary in regards to Quirk's article entitled...
Mysticism/Deism
Posted by Sarah on 04-22-02
In response to quirk. I think trying to compare Tolkien's story to any...
About Arwen and Tom
Posted by Narya on 04-22-02
The absence of Tom Bombadil didn't make me unhappy. I apologize to...
Re: Eagles Again
Posted by Fernando the Quenya Learner on 04-23-02
Okay, Renee, here's a complete and total answer (hopefully) to your...
Of Eagles, Councils and Grey Areas
Posted by Everett V. on 04-23-02
For the past week or so, I have watched the discussion of why Frodo...
Regarding Gandalf the Grey
Posted by Anthony T. on 04-23-02
Gandalf the Grey is physically destroyed during his battle with the...
Re: Gandalf the Grey Area
Posted by Greg H. on 04-23-02
This is a reply to Curious George's questions about Gandalf. Gandalf is...
Re: Elrond's Council and Moria
Posted by Brett C. on 04-24-02
Pj actually discussed the difficulty of filming the council scene on the...
Discussions and Responses
Posted by Diana on 04-24-02
Brett, we just can't trust technology. I don't think anyone is holding...
On the Absence of Tom Bombadil
Posted by Graham on 04-24-02
I know that there are quite a few readers loyal to the books who were...
Fluidshaggy on Saruman
Posted by John R. on 04-24-02
My recollection is that Saruman went "bad" before he ever looked into...
Religion, Gandalf, and More Eagles
Posted by Diana on 04-25-02
Lailam, you might have heard "God helps those who help themselves." It...
Gandalf the Clear White
Posted by Roger McE. on 04-25-02
The previous artilce asked questions regarding Gandalf and his...
My Thoughts on the Current Debate
Posted by Janelle on 04-25-02
I must agree with Sarah, Olwarz and all you others who have writen...
Disappointing Bits of FOTR
Posted by Mark C. on 04-25-02
There has been some discussion about the bits of FOTR that were...
Tolkien and C.S. Lewis
Posted by Sarah on 04-26-02
Another thought about Quirk's article. About Tolkien not liking Lewis...
Eagles...
Posted by Annatar on 04-26-02
Some people have said that the eagles only take action when ordered...
Gandalf the White
Posted by Gothamock on 04-26-02
To give a simple answer, yes he dies. In the books, Gandalf "passes"...
To Greg H.
Posted by Rachael on 04-26-02
Galadriel is not the oldest elf. Cirdan (pronounced Keerdan, I think) is...
Powerful Sauron
Posted by Greg H. on 04-27-02
This is in response to Everett V's comment the other day on the...
On Eagles and Grey Areas
Posted by Richard P. on 04-27-02
Your absolutley right, the Eagles are refered to as the "Heralds of...
Ring of Barahir
Posted by Beren on 04-27-02
Well, there was one positive thing in the film. The Ring of Barahir...
Council of Elrond and Stuff
Posted by Lem on 04-27-02
I agree with Brett C. about the council and that the other men, dwarves...
A New FotR Film
Posted by Drac0n1us on 04-28-02
Having seen the Fellowship of the Ring I was extremely dissappointed in...
Religious Influence on Tolkien
Posted by Imran H. on 04-28-02
Having read the books recently I have come to the conclusion that the...
Symbols and Paralells Unintentional
Posted by Danny S. on 04-28-02
I find it interesting how the debate over symbols and allegorical elements...
Allegory in Tolkien
Posted by Al Gore on 04-28-02
It's very simple, an allegory is a story that is a sort of blow-by-blow...
The Council of Elrond and Stuff
Posted by Lem on 04-28-02
I agree with Janelle that our beliefs will influence our writing and that...
Saruman and Council
Posted by Diana on 04-29-02
Fluidshaggy and John, you could both be right. Saruman might not have...
Great Answers, Movies, and Interpretations
Posted by Diana on 04-29-02
You all provide such great answers in your essays, and help me to see...
Eagles in the Silmarillion
Posted by Katabasis on 04-29-02
In regards to furthering the Eagles debate, aside from what has been...
Gandalf and Gaffs
Posted by Brett C. on 04-29-02
A very quick weigh in to the Gandalf discussion. Yes, he does return to...
The Eagles Have Landed
Posted by Brett C. on 04-30-02
Richard P makes reference to an idea that the eagles are some form of...
Eagles and Power Struggles
Posted by Everett V. on 04-30-02
Two things.
First of all, thanks to Annatar for the correction on what...
Boromir
Posted by Barristan S. on 04-30-02
Actually, I thought the movie did a pretty decent job portraying Boromir.
In Regards to Fight Scenes
Posted by Jonny P. on 04-30-02
In response to Lem saying that the battle scenes "were hard to see...
|
