|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Movie Changes and DracOn1Us
Posted by Diana on 05-15-02
DracOn1Us, despite the arrogance and greed, I still respected Boromir...
Amon Hen
Posted by Brett C. on 05-15-02
This is for Tavra, as I go through the back log of essays I've missed...
Re: Staffs
Posted by Brett C. on 05-15-02
Gandalf did indeed lose his staff in Moria, Richard, since it breaks and...
TTT Trailer
Posted by Brett C. on 05-15-02
My third 'short' esay for the day. I'm not sure if the trailer you down...
Frodo's Dream, Gandalf's Staff & Glamdring
Posted by Tim Stone on 05-15-02
If you recall, in one of Frodo's dreams (at Bombadil's house, I believe...
Re: The Birds on Caradhras and Sam
Posted by drac0n1us on 05-16-02
Good question Lem, the birds on Caradhas were Crebain of Dunland...
Crebain and Stuff
Posted by Brett C. on 05-16-02
Still out there defending PJ's blackriders. People say they should have...
Picky People
Posted by Aven on 05-16-02
In my opinion the criticisms expressed about FOTR the movie are...
Saruman's Army
Posted by Cathrine on 05-16-02
In response to the article about being bored but coming up with the topic...
Re: Finally Some Common Sense
Posted by Cathrine on 05-16-02
I think it would be great to hear all the things people liked about the...
Re: Gandalf, Alchemist...
Posted by Kailam on 05-17-02
Simon: Wow!! I really liked your analogy of Gandalf and his place in...
PS: Gandalf in General
Posted by Kailam on 05-17-02
By the way (I should have inlcuded this in my last post), everyone's...
TTT Title, Movie, and Isuldur's Blood
Posted by Diana on 05-17-02
I agree Beechbone. TTT was written and titled decades before our recent...
To Beechbone: I Wouldn't Worry
Posted by Razors on 05-17-02
I've seen comments about that stupid petition popping up all over the...
Re: Finally Some Common Sense
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-17-02
Apologies for driving you nuts, but let me speak in defence for all the...
The Palantir
Posted by Brett C. on 05-18-02
Anthony, by interpretation of how the Palantir operate, based on the text...
Ents, Cirdan, Nazgul, Movie, Topics, and Saruman
Posted by Diana on 05-18-02
Welcome Melodie! We can discuss any LotR topics here, so go ahead...
Arwen and Boredom
Posted by Kailam on 05-18-02
Anthony: I think your new topic idea is an interesting one. Some have...
The Twin Towers, To Be Or Not To Be
Posted by Sarah on 05-18-02
Some people can be soooooo dumb. Hello! Tolkien named it The Two...
My Point on the Arwen Subject
Posted by Tomas Bergström on 05-18-02
This debate about Arwen starts to bore me to death, but I have to...
Mixed Feelings
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-19-02
In a way, I think I've always both relished and dreaded a blockbuster...
Rambo on the Weathertop
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-19-02
This article is in response to Brett C. who argued that the Weathertop...
Response to Razors
Posted by Beechbone on 05-19-02
First, there is mention of the war assaulting the dwarves and elves up...
Confusion, Jokes, and Other Battles
Posted by Diana on 05-19-02
David, many people who didn't read the books couldn't understand what...
What About the Barrow-Downs?
Posted by Galadhrim on 05-19-02
I think it's interesting that the film makers decided to omit Tom Bombadil...
Thoughts on Arwen
Posted by Galadhrim on 05-20-02
My personal analyzation of Arwen: I think she's an incredible character...
Re: Beechbone's
Posted by Galadhrim on 05-20-02
Beechbone, I couldn't agree more. I have all sympathy for those who lost...
Re: Gandalf, Alchemist and Magician
Posted by rC on 05-20-02
I really don't think Gandalf could have just gone with Gwahir to Orodruin...
Re: Criticisms of FotR Movie
Posted by rC on 05-20-02
I really think Jackson did a good job condensing the movie and we...
Responses
Posted by Lem on 05-20-02
Like David I only became an avid Tolkien reader after I saw the movie...
Re: Staffs
Posted by Richard P on 05-21-02
Indeedy, Gandalf does lose his staff in Moria... my bad!!!
But in...
Re: Glamdring
Posted by Fingolfin on 05-21-02
Tom, I understand what you mean about Gandalf not wearing Glamdring...
Two Towers... Insensitive
Posted by Will on 05-21-02
Are these people idiots? They propose to change the name of a story...
Imagination vs Choice of Actors
Posted by David on 05-21-02
Just a quick response to Brett C's musing about which actors/actresses...
Questions About Lothlorien
Posted by Altariel on 05-21-02
Hello, I am new to this message board, although I daily read all of the...
The Whole Arwen Thing
Posted by Arina on 05-22-02
I had no objections to seeing Arwen in the first or even the second...
Gondor to Shire Journey
Posted by Fingolfin on 05-22-02
Brett, you're absolutely right that the journey from Gondor to the Shire...
Aven, Cathrine, and Brett C.
Posted by Diana on 05-22-02
Aven, I agree that some people are picky, but I did expect changes...
TTT Petition
Posted by Laurie on 05-22-02
Ok, I've seen the petition to change the name of TTT. I have to admit...
Bob the Builder and Razors
Posted by Diana on 05-22-02
Bob the Builder, don't worry. It wasn't your fault. You weren't attacking...
Arwen Debate, Complaints, and Boredom
Posted by Diana on 05-23-02
Tomas and Kailam, I agree that the Arwen debate has been going on...
Arwen: The Much-Needed Heroine
Posted by Jessie on 05-23-02
I'd like to throw my two cents in about Arwen. I agree that it was...
Re: The Twin Towers, To Be Or Not To Be
Posted by Richard P. on 05-23-02
In response to Sarah. Firstly, you say that Aragorn shouts Earendil...
Lots of Things
Posted by Danny on 05-23-02
First off, I think it is sad that people would sign a petition like they...
Agreements
Posted by Diana on 05-23-02
Galadhrim, I agree (Guys, if this offends you, don't read). Society has...
Re: What About the Barrow Downs?
Posted by David on 05-24-02
I'm afraid I put myself in the 'Thank God They Got Rid of Bombadil'...
Gandalf's Changing Staff
Posted by Simon on 05-24-02
Watching the movie again and thinking about the recent debate here...
Cut Arwen Some Slack!
Posted by Lady of Rohan on 05-24-02
As a self-described LOTR purist, I admit I was a little miffed with a few...
About Lorien Questions
Posted by Galactus on 05-24-02
This is in response to some of the ideas Altariel brought up. Something...
Characters, Satisfaction, and Glamdring
Posted by Alowyn on 05-24-02
This is my first submission, so please bear with my verbal fumblings...
|
