|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Tom Bombadil
Posted by Bob M. on 05-01-02
Tom Bombadil has always been one of my favorite characters in the...
Tolkien vs. Lewis: In 3 Rounds
Posted by Match of the Century on 05-01-02
Despite one's hopeful sentiment, Tolkien became embittered and...
Response to Draconus
Posted by Barristan S. on 05-01-02
Unfortunately, there are a great number of flaws in that arguement. As...
Cirdan
Posted by Greg H. on 05-01-02
Yes, Rachael, you are certainly right that Cirdan is the eldest elf...
Re: A New FotR Film
Posted by Razors on 05-02-02
So Drac0n1us, you want to see a 24-hour-long FOTR divided into six...
Boromir: Movie vs. Book
Posted by Jamie H. on 05-02-02
I have to disagree with Lem's comments regarding Boromir. I came away...
Defending Boromir
Posted by fluidshaggy on 05-02-02
I have to strongly disagree with drac0n1us' assertion that Boromir comes...
Ent Wives Dead or Alive?
Posted by Tomas B. on 05-02-02
I've got another question about Ents that maybe one of you out their...
Re: Gandalf and Gaffs
Posted by Kailam on 05-03-02
I submitted an article like this before, but it never got posted for some...
Criticisms of the FOTR Movie
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-03-02
Before I upset a lot of diehard fans, a few points should be made first...
Eagles as Maia
Posted by Richard P. on 05-03-02
Maybe I am wrong in saying that they are Maia (or that the very first...
I Don't Have An Article Title
Posted by Tavra on 05-03-02
Ok, first off, does anyone know of any good LOTR chat rooms?
Second...
Movies and Essays
Posted by Diana on 05-04-02
Well, I just finished "The Return of the King" about an hour ago. I'll soon...
Some More Things
Posted by Diana on 05-04-02
Here are some things I just forgot to mention. First, from that website...
Tolkien: Author of the Century
Posted by Kailam on 05-04-02
Has anyone here ever read the book "J.R.R. Tolkien: Author of the...
Entwives, Movie, and Boromir
Posted by Diana on 05-04-02
Tomas, it could be either true or made up. Some of the characters...
Criticisms of the FOTR Movie
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-08-02
Before I upset a lot of diehard fans, a few points should be made first...
Arwen vs Glorfindel
Posted by caity on 05-08-02
I have just a quick question here. Why did they cut Glorfindel out of the...
Entwives: Dead or Alive?
Posted by John R. on 05-08-02
Tolkien never answered the question of whether or not the Entwives...
Tree-man in the Shire
Posted by Brett C. on 05-08-02
Yes, Tomas, I picked up on that reference to, though of course not the...
Be Content
Posted by Scooter on 05-09-02
This is my first time writing an entry for this forum, so bear with me...
Re: Critisisms of the FOTR Movie
Posted by Kailam on 05-09-02
I have to agree with Bob on some of his gripes. Particularly, the gripe...
To Bob the Builder and Similar People
Posted by Tavra on 05-09-02
Ok, Bob, I understand your gripes about the movie. And everyone...
Re: Criticisms...
Posted by BA on 05-09-02
While I don't share your specific reasons for the film's unsatisfying...
Gandalf & Goblins
Posted by Curious George on 05-09-02
I'd like to thank everyone for submitting their articles about Gandalf's...
Entwives, Staff, and Movies
Posted by Diana on 05-10-02
Kailam and Tomas, I just checked the parts in the book you mentioned...
Debate Forum and Essays
Posted by Diana on 05-10-02
Thank you Kailam! I've never heard of that book, but anyone really...
Re: Boromir and His Portrayel
Posted by drac0n1us on 05-10-02
Indeed I greatly respect Sean Bean's acting ability and his portrayel of...
TTT Trailer
Posted by drac0n1us on 05-10-02
Well, I just dled the TTT trailer from morpheus and boy does it look good...
Wizards Staffs
Posted by Richard P. on 05-10-02
In response to Kailam, I am pretty sure that in the books Gandalf is...
Old Man Willow and Sam
Posted by Melodie on 05-11-02
OK, here goes: First, I want to say that this is my first time doing...
Of Dwarves and Elves
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-11-02
I agree with a couple of Diana's points about the movie. Namely, that...
Entwives, Weathertop and Stuff
Posted by Lem on 05-11-02
I agree with everyone who said so that Weathertop was not done to...
Re: Arwen vs. Glorfindel
Posted by Cathrine on 05-11-02
Well I agree they shouldn't have cut Glorfindel out of the movie, there...
On Galadriel, Power, Etc.
Posted by Mark on 05-11-02
Greg H ... Elrond's power from exposure to a Silmaril? It is clear...
Bob the Builder is Right
Posted by Beechbone on 05-12-02
In response to Bob the Builder's criticisms of the movie, I must say...
The Nazgul and Arwen
Posted by Brett C. on 05-12-02
Bob and Caity, you make some good points for discussion. The...
I Am Sooooooo Bored, People!
Posted by Anthony T. on 05-12-02
Hey everyone! As much as I love a good debate about Tolkien, and...
On What Aragorn Shouts
Posted by Richard P. on 05-12-02
I believe that actaully what Aragorn shoults is Elendil, who was the...
Further to my Earlier Criticisms
Posted by Bob the Builder on 05-12-02
Thanks for those who commented on my original criticisms of the FOTR...
Re: Arwen vs Glorfindel
Posted by Razors on 05-13-02
Caity asks: "Arwen didn't do a thing in the book, why do they feel she...
Gandalf, Alchemist and Magician
Posted by Simon on 05-13-02
The clue about why Gandalf does not simply magic himself out of the...
Re: To Bob the Builder and Similar People
Posted by Olorin on 05-13-02
This is just a correction to Tavra's earlier article about the movie's...
Finally Some Common Sense
Posted by Danny on 05-13-02
I hear you Scooter! In honesty, it drives me nuts sometimes to hear all...
Troupe of Fools
Posted by Beechbone on 05-13-02
First, let's read the story: Lord of the Rings
Madness Staff Reporter...
Criticisms of FotR Movie
Posted by David on 05-14-02
I think some of you may be going a little overboard with regards to your...
Essay Postings and Accepting Differences
Posted by Diana on 05-14-02
Welcome Scooter! Feel free to post your essays. I don't mind listening...
Entwives, Whips, Staff, and Movie
Posted by Diana on 05-14-02
Tomas, as I mentioned in the previous essay, Tolkien never made...
Ents in the Shire
Posted by Tavra on 05-14-02
Ok, about the ents in the Shire. I think that Tolkien maybe just put it...
Another Question
Posted by Razors on 05-14-02
Ok - we know that while Sauron's armies are attacking Gondor, there...
|
