|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 A: Aragorn
Posted by Elendur on 02-16-04
"Cast aside the ranger, become who you were born to be." The ranger was cast aside, but the king did not return. He was replaced by someone who...
To: Elendur and FotR
Posted by Lem on 02-16-04
I agree about what you said concerning Aragorn, except that I expect the Palantir scene will be included in the extended edition. It was mentioned...
Returned
Posted by Orangeblossom on 02-17-04
I have very relieved to have returned to normal life. At School we just hosted KCACTF (a huge theater festival) so I have not had any time for...
Not Much, Just Some Questions
Posted by Tuor on 02-18-04
I had a post, but it might steal something from Aragorn's A-Z, so I'll just say this: E for Elves (or Elfs, whichever is correct). The bloopers...
Quick Article
Posted by Pip on 02-18-04
Orangeblossom, One word: Ebay. Quick, go to this link. http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=3387463410&category=2277 The...
B: Black Breath
Posted by Elendur on 02-18-04
"Nazgul! Wraiths on wings!" Oddly enough, Gollum's words in The Two Towers foreshadowed what would eventually happen: With the removel of the...
Rohan Or Gondor?
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 02-18-04
Hello everyone. Here's a poll for everyone: Let's say that we're all humans, just for this - then you can go right back to being hobbits, elves,...
Dead Marshes
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 02-18-04
I am finally reading the Weapons and Warfare book. They mention something about how it takes Frodo, Sam, and Gollum about a day or two to get...
Sorry Elendur
Posted by Tuor on 02-18-04
I said "Aragorn's A-Z" in my last article instead of "Elendur's A-Z". I guess it was the title that threw me off. Sorry.
Re: Rohan Or Gondor
Posted by Artanis on 02-19-04
I would definitely pick Rohan. It is more agricultural, so you could live independently if you wanted. They seem to have a really strong bond and...
C: Cracks of Doom
Posted by Elendur on 02-19-04
The Goal. The climax. They really didn't do a bad job. OK, they did a good job("Clever Hobbits, to climb so...
Response to Raggedyanndy, and Frodo 'downsized'
Posted by Bob Praz on 02-20-04
In response to the Gondor vs Rohan poll, I must say I would personally choose Gondor. I'm more of a modern or indoors person, I'm afraid, so I...
D: Denethor's Pyre
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 02-20-04
D: Denethor's Pyre. (Yes this could be under P, but who cares?) Anyway. Why, oh why did Shadowfax knock Denethor onto the pyre? Why oh why did...
D: Denethor
Posted by Elendur on 02-20-04
Denethor. Ouch. I could go on and on about this one but instead I'll tell you to look at my post on 1-09-04 called "Denethor"(the answer to the...
Gondor Or Rohan?
Posted by Jevic of Highgate on 02-20-04
Thats way to easy. Gondor would be my choice. Just seeing it blew me away in theaters. The White Tower, all the mountains, the White Tree, all the...
Frodo Pushing Gollum??
Posted by inthelandofmordor on 02-20-04
Let me first start off by saying that I have read the books and I also initially thought that Frodo pushed Gollum into the lava at the end of the...
E: Eomer
Posted by Elendur on 02-20-04
Don't get me wrong, I thought Eomer was well portrayed and well acted. But remember the scene where he finds Theoden wounded and Theoden says:...
Let Me Think...
Posted by Pippin on 02-20-04
To the person who asked where would you live Gondor or Rohan, my responce is I DUNNO ^_^ Gondor is really pretty but I'm afraid of hights^_^...
Gondor
Posted by Aragorn on 02-20-04
Now as you may have gussed I would like to be a Gondorian. The reason is that I just think it would be realy cool to live in Minas Tirith. I mean...
B Revised
Posted by Pip on 02-21-04
I have to refute B here. Not that the black breath thing isn't valid. However, my choice would have been B:Beregond. I mean really people;...
Frodo Pushing Gollum
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 02-21-04
Hey all. After reading inthelandofmordor's post, I remembered a part of ROTK (the book, not the movie) that would back up what he says. At the...
I'm Back
Posted by Took on 02-21-04
Hey everybody! I considered putting "Well, I'm back" as my article title, but thats been used about 15,000,000,000 times. I decided to stay away...
Is That Beregond?
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 02-21-04
Hello folks. I've a question that I would like your opinion on. Remember the unnamed Gondorian soldier (the one who says, "Long has Lord...
A Where Would Ya Live Question
Posted by Pippin on 02-22-04
Ok seeing how everyone is on the topic of "Where would ya live gondor or rohan" i have a lil question that is simular... Where would you live if...
Re: Where Would You Live?
Posted by Lem on 02-22-04
If given the choice of anywhere in Middle Earth, I would choose to live in Rivendell, because not only do the elves live there, and it would be...
Where Would I Live?
Posted by Tuor on 02-22-04
Oh, the horrors of being tall. Clothes don't fit right, buying cars based on leg room and shoes based on what's available instead of what you...
Beregond/Imrahil in the Movie
Posted by Bob Praz on 02-22-04
Good question, M. Underhill. I also figured that gondorian captain was Beregond, even if they didn't mention his name nor give him a great...
F: Farimar
Posted by Elendur on 02-22-04
He's got to be one of the best characters in the book and they destroyed him. Completely mauled. Where was the man who "was stern and commanding,...
A Quick Question Concerning Aragorn
Posted by Lilly on 02-22-04
Sorry for staying away so long (though I doubt you are). Quick question. In the ROTK (movie) the King of the Dead seems surprised at Aragorn's...
Anywhere in Middle Earth?
Posted by Jevic of Highgate on 02-22-04
Thats even easier than the Rohan or Gondor question. Lothlórien man. If she was still there, I would trade all the world to live in the same place...
I'm Sick of Elendur
Posted by Mr. Blonde on 02-23-04
I have read The Lord of the Rings more times then I can count, I love the books and have ever since I finished Fellowship for the first time when I...
G: Gandalf
Posted by Elendur on 02-23-04
It would be hard to improve on Brett C's post on 1-26-04, "Yes, Everett, the dam has burst"(which everyone should read) , for a list of...
Re: I'm Sick of Elendur
Posted by Elendur on 02-23-04
It took a while, but I'm finally getting the sort of response I expected, and a chance to repeat something I've said several times: I LOVE the...
H: Half-elven
Posted by Elendur on 02-23-04
The biggest problem with the Half-Elven in ROTK was not Elrond coming to Dunharrow(even though I would have liked to see the Grey Company), it was...
Where in Middle Earth
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 02-23-04
Hey all. Well, I would still pick Rohan, but I wouldn't mind living in the Shire, either. It's so peaceful there. But, I am very non-smoking, so I...
Replies and Stuff
Posted by Artanis on 02-24-04
If I could live anywhere in ME, my house would be in The Shire, my cabin in Rohan, and my condo in Rivendell. :) As far as the changes in the...
I Would Live In....
Posted by Orangeblossom on 02-24-04
As a 20 year old, I am very short. I am not even 5 feet so you tall people do not complain about height. My theater friends have been calling me...
Ok Elendur
Posted by Mr. Blonde on 02-24-04
All I can say is, my bad. I was under the impression that you were one of those LOTR movie hating purists. I also agree that the movies are not...
Insight Into Tolkien
Posted by Thorongil on 02-24-04
In The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien on p.270 there is a commentary of Tolkien's about the first LOTR movie planned. It is 8 pages long, and Tolkien...
A Subject From Strider
Posted by Strider on 02-24-04
I think we need to start talking about Tolkien's other works, such as "The Hobbit" or the "The Silmarillion". I would like to know something.
Where... and What About Frodo?
Posted by Annatar on 02-24-04
Where would I like to live in Middle-Earth. Well I used to have a nice little place in Eregion but the neighbours were such a boorish lot. One had...
Comparisons
Posted by Eonwe on 02-24-04
The problem with the book-film comparisons on this forum is that they really only work one way: the film is compared to the book, but not the book...
Fav Tolkien Book & Beorn
Posted by Jevic of Highgate on 02-26-04
Well my personal favorite Tolkien book has to be The Silmarillion. Although I abosolutely fell in love with The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings (On...
To Eonwe
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 02-26-04
Okay, um, interesting idea, except for one problem: Tolkien came first. Plus, what you said about all of Jackson's ideas that are in the movie...
Living in Middle Earth
Posted by acer rubrum on 02-26-04
Where would I live in Middle Earth? Most definitely, the Shire. The Peace-loving, agrarian lifestyle is very appealing. The Party Tree is by far the...
RotK Characters
Posted by Thorongil on 02-26-04
I thought the FOTR was great. I thought theTT was a fine movie. But my opinion of ROTK is very low. (2 out of 3, still not bad P.J.) My main...
I: Imrahil
Posted by Elendur on 02-26-04
OK, this one's a bit nitpicky, but it really bugs me how Imrahil(or the person we think is Imrahil) was done. His ONE line is: "It is as...
Valar Eating Hobbit?
Posted by Pippin on 02-26-04
Ok I'm getting confusedbut did you say that the Valar eat the hobbits? how do you know this I'm so confused (and frightend) I mean poor Bilbo...
Faith of Tolkien
Posted by Jevic of Highgate on 02-26-04
Living in Alabama, there always seems to be a religious controversy surrounding anything that suddenly becomes popular. And being a Christian myself...
Bad Advice
Posted by Thorongil on 02-28-04
One of the things I liked about the TT was that the battles are realistic. In the ROTK, The characters give somevery bad orders and advice. When...
|
