|
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Mouth of Sauron in EE?
Posted by Took on 01-08-04
Hi peoples! The Mouth of Sauron was in the ROTK video game . . . does that mean it will be in the EE? I sure hope so! The movie shows the orcs...
Debate Forum
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 01-08-04
This is a debate forum so I think I am going to start a discussion. Not about Harry vs. LOTR, not about Allegory or Christianity and not about the...
To - About My Namesake
Posted by Tuor on 01-08-04
Maybe we should start calling you "hyphen." Ha. I also felt Frodo was trying to get the ring back, not trying to destroy it, and he and Gollum...
More Things About RotK
Posted by Magic Fire on 01-09-04
First of all, I never for once thought that the Witch King's demise looked like the witch's in the Wizard of Oz, but, then, we are all different...
Gollum
Posted by Orangeblossom on 01-09-04
I have to write quickly so I can go to school and be on time. But I think that Gollum would have died with the Ring. He being so connected to the...
Glamdring of Gondolin
Posted by Imlar on 01-09-04
In response to ";" about Glamdring, it is the same one as Turgon's. In The Hobbit, Elrond states "These are not troll-make. They are old swords...
Denethor
Posted by Elendur on 01-09-04
Does anyone think that Denethor was done badly? In the books he was a proud but strong leader, until he fought with Sauron through the palantir, and...
Does Anyone Know What Species Sauron Is?
Posted by Knal of Gondor on 01-09-04
Thanks for the last anwser Artanis, But does anyone know what species sauron is. Is he like a evil wizard or demented elf? someone please answer my...
Movies Fall Short
Posted by Jetrine on 01-10-04
The Lord of the Rings movies were a nearly a complete failure. It started going down hill shortly after Bilbo left the Shire. They teased us with...
Answer for Knal of Gondor
Posted by Elendur on 01-10-04
Sauron is a Maia, like Gandalf, Saruman, and the Balrogs. Maiar(the plural) are sometimes compared to angels. In the First Age Maiar could come and...
Selling the EE
Posted by Elendur on 01-10-04
I liked ROTK and the first two extended editions but this is pathetic. Peter Jackson cut The Witch King's challenge at the gate but left in the...
Supporting Orangeblossom & Other Matters
Posted by Lilly on 01-10-04
Gollum would have died with the ring...He said so himself, to Sam, on the slopes of mt. Doom. He said he would die into the dust. Dussst.
Did You Miss Me?
Posted by Pippin on 01-10-04
Probly not but that's ok ^_^ I have not posted in a long time mainly becouse of school and Basketball and cheerleading... But that's OK any way I...
Saruman & the Istari
Posted by hamfast68 on 01-10-04
Saruman was an Istari. Which were five or possibly more beings that were sent to Middle Earth by the Valar, who were angelic spirits. Their job was...
Sam-ring-frodo
Posted by Uruviel on 01-10-04
Ok, this is MY personal opinion of this. When Sam rescues Frodo in Minas Morgul, and he tells Frodo that he took the ring for safekeeping, it's...
Saurons Species
Posted by jazz_man on 01-10-04
i'm not sure but i'm pretty sure Sauron use to be one of the Maia (spelling?), once even good in heart but he was corrupted by Morgoth. So I guess...
Gullom's Fate
Posted by Imlar on 01-11-04
Sorry, Orangeblossom, but I don't think I agree with you about the outcome of Gullom after the ring's destruction. It's an interesting question...
Sauron Reply
Posted by gaffer on 01-11-04
Sauron was a Maiar, the servants and helpers of the Valar. According to the Silmarillion, like the Valar they existed before the world, and were of...
For Knal of Gondor
Posted by Glamdring on 01-11-04
Sauron is a maiar, which means a minor Valar, just like the Istari (Saruman, Gandalf, Radagast). During the First Age, he was Morgoth's...
Gollum and Denethor
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 01-11-04
First things first: Gollum. I think that he would have somehow died with the Ring. Either because he was just so connected with the Ring, so that it...
Sauron and Denethor
Posted by Lem on 01-11-04
Sauron is a Maia like Gandalf and Saruman, except he was corrupted by Melkor (as far as I remember, feel free to correct me). I agree that...
A Word to Jarrickon Half-elven...
Posted by Uruviel on 01-11-04
I liked the article you wrote about Gandalf being the steward. However, I just wanted to mention that you should not have said that he was "the"...
Gollum Was Doomed
Posted by Tuor on 01-11-04
I also think Gollum would die with the ring's demise, mostly because he would probably dive in after it. Not to mention that he was so old and...
Some Relevant, and Some Random Discussion
Posted by - on 01-11-04
Well, hello all! Hope you have all been well. Firstly, to Frodo_Lives: Yes! Organised discussion. I'm loving it already. About Gollum - I would...
Tom Bombadil
Posted by Elendur on 01-13-04
I don't think even Tolkien was sure about what Tom was. I know I've never read anything that specified his race. Tolkien had invented him and...
Re: Uruviel
Posted by Lilly on 01-13-04
I think it was kind of both: on one hand, Frodo wanted nothing but the ring back and safely around his neck, on the other, he didn't want to let...
I Feel Sorry for Some People.
Posted by inthelandofmordor on 01-13-04
First things first, in response to the comment that PJ left certain scenes out of the theatrical versions simply to sell the ExtDVDs, I just don't...
Longing for a Home
Posted by Isilwen on 01-13-04
Now, I'm new to this site, actually, so I don't know if any of you ADORE LOTR as much as I do.(I'm not saying that as in 'you don't like them...
What is Your Problem?!
Posted by Pippin on 01-13-04
To Jetrine: I really think that Peter Jackson did a really good job on this movie. I know that there are people who liked the book beter than the...
Tom Is...
Posted by Pippin on 01-13-04
I really not sure about what speicies Tom Bombadil is but if i'd have to guess i'd say... Hobbit or a maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan or something like...
Favorite LotR Character
Posted by Pippin on 01-13-04
I know its an old question but i really want to know what is your favorite LOTR character and why.^_^ I think you can allready guess what mine is...
Re: Uruviel
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 01-13-04
Thats a really interesting thought but I think you are wrong. Now I would say you were right if I hadn't read the books. The reson I say this...
Re: Gandalf the Steward/re: Movies Fall Short....
Posted by Uruviel on 01-14-04
Ok, just to clarify, in the post "Gandalf the steward" it talked about Gandalf and the other Istari. That was all correct information, except I...
Gandalf
Posted by Lem on 01-14-04
I'm watching this documentary on Lord of the Rings which is on TV here (east coast US) and PJ was saying that he didn't want Gandalf to seem...
Questions
Posted by Orangeblossom on 01-14-04
Questions: 1. Besides Fellowship of the Ring, does Tom appear anywhere else? 2. Do any of the sets still remain or where all torn down...
The Blue Wizards
Posted by Elendur on 01-14-04
In answer to -, you probably already know about everything I'm going to say here because I'm guessing that you found the names of the Blue...
To Uruviel
Posted by Jarrickon Half-elven on 01-14-04
Did I say "THE Steward?" My apologies, you are quite right; the Istari were numbered five, with Saruman the White at their head, followed by...
The Blue Wizards
Posted by Bob Praz on 01-14-04
I haven't posted in a while due to an overabundance of homework (which I still have, but am partly ignoring), but since I've looked at this...
Wait - What?? Duh!
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 01-14-04
Okay, I just read that article about Jimmy Carter's interview, and I'm so confused... It was fake? Well, what about that thing at the end...
Dimand of Long Cleeves
Posted by Pippin on 01-14-04
Ok if you read pg. 1071-1072 you will read about the later events in the lord of the rings. I am doing a project on Pippin for school. And in the...
I See in Your Eyes...
Posted by Mr. Underhill on 01-15-04
Hello folks, I've been away from my computer for a while, and it looks like I've been missing some good debates. Bummer. But anyway, I had a...
Exactly!!!!
Posted by Isilwen on 01-15-04
TO:inthelandofmordor. I agree with the excellent point you made to Jetrine (Titled: When movies fall short) Her reasoning was ridiculous! She also...
Re: Elendur
Posted by Isilwen on 01-15-04
I was wondering about Tom Bombadil myself. You said Tolkien wrote about him long before LOTR and I wanted to enquire what you were referring to.
Happy Birthday Orlando Bloom!
Posted by Took on 01-15-04
For those of you who don't know, today (January 13)is Orlando Bloom's birthday! He is turning 27. So if there is any chance in the world that...
Re: Frodo_lives, Lilly, Pippin, Isilwen
Posted by Uruviel on 01-15-04
This is my Re: post to those who posted on the 13th. I'd like to note that I will not be sarcastic to you when replying to your posts. (Except...
More About Selling the EE
Posted by Elendur on 01-15-04
First: My brother wrote the first post about the Witch-King Gandalf scene, but I agree with him. It doesn't make sense to me that PJ put the...
Favorite Character
Posted by Elendur on 01-15-04
I have a lot of favorite characters but one of the most interesting is Elendur. He is(as far as I know) mentioned only once, in the chapter "The...
Re : Favourite Character in Answer to Pippin's Pos
Posted by Glamdring on 01-15-04
My favourite character is undoubtfully Gollum. I just think he is so well-developed ! I mean, he isn't just a plain evil character like so many...
A Little More About Tom Bombadil
Posted by - on 01-16-04
Well, I hope that this post won't be an information overload on Tom Bombadil, but this is what I know about him: 'Maia master of Old Forest.
Re: Fav LotR Character
Posted by Artanis on 01-16-04
My favorite character from the books would be Samwise Gamgee simply because he is so selfless and loyal. I wish I had some of his qualities...he's...
|
