TolkienMovies.com - Lord of the Rings movie news, photos, rumors, and more

Home
Words - News stories
People - Cast and characters
Images - Image gallery
Links - Related sites
Forum - Moderated debate forum
Debate (2012)
Debate (2011)
Debate (2010)
Debate (2009)
Debate (2008)
Debate (2007)
Debate (2006)
Debate (2005)
Debate (2004)
Debate (2003)
Debate (2002)
Debate (2001)
Debate (2000)
Debate (1999)


Debate (2004)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

Narnia
Posted by kat on 06-23-04
I absolutly love TCON! Ever since I heard they were making it into a movie I've been anticipating it. Is there any info out there about who was...

Re:re:truth of Bombadil and Tcon
Posted by Lilly on 06-23-04
LOL...I'm not sure what the author of that would have to say about Goldberry...hmmmm... And, yes, I'm a HUGE fan of the Chronicles. I'm pumped...

Tcon
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 06-24-04
Someone askes if Weta was working on TCON and the answer to that question is yes. Richard Taylor is going to head up special affects. That means...

Tcon
Posted by Lem on 06-24-04
ah, man, when i was little i used to looove the Lion, the WItch and the Wardrobe movie! hahaha despite the dismal special effects. I haven't read...

Unnumbered Tears
Posted by Annatar on 06-25-04
Just wondering, wouldnt it be great if the story leading up to and of the Great battle of Unnumbered Tears, was expanded and given the LOTRs...

My Favorite Book
Posted by Danny on 06-25-04
My favorite book (not movie) is Two Towers. I like it the best for several reasons. The biggest reason I like it is that every page of that story is...

Tcon
Posted by Tuor on 06-26-04
I still read TCON from time to time. Actually, I keep the series on my bookshelf right next to my various LOTR books and such. I remember being...

Hello Everyone
Posted by Nienna on 06-26-04
Hello everyone, I'm "Nienna". I've been reading posts here off and on for a few months now. I thought I'd register and join (try to join)...

RotK on Pay Per View
Posted by Magic Fire on 06-26-04
Hi Everyone: Has anyone rented ROTK on pay per view yet? They are advertising extra footage not included in the Theatrical edition.Evidently they...

Welcome Nienna!
Posted by Elendur on 06-26-04
We haven't had any new members for a while, so it's great to see someone but us actually reads our posts. Hope you have a great time...

RotK on Ppv; and the Fourth Age
Posted by Bob Praz on 06-26-04
To answer your question, Magic Fire, pay-per-view (PPV) is apparently showing the behind-the-scenes documentary "A Director's Journey: A Quest...

4th Age
Posted by Danny on 06-27-04
Are you telling me that LOTR isn't actually history? 8). At least I have always thought that was the most entertaining way to think about it even...

Fourth Age and Beyond
Posted by - on 06-28-04
Picking up on the recent speculations on what happened to Hobbits etc after the 4rth Age, I think that I remember reading somewhere that the...

Welcome
Posted by Annatar on 06-28-04
Hi, just thought I'd welcome Nienna, look forward to reading posts from you. Oh and by-the-by if you want shiny rings with nice stones inset, I'm...

Thanks, and About Nienna
Posted by Nienna on 06-28-04
First, thanks for such a warm welcome everyone. To Annatar-I'm a big fan of your posts, they make me laugh. I appreciate your humor.

Innovation
Posted by Annatar on 06-29-04
Just occured to me that Elves would not be the most innovative beings ever. Seriously, when it comes to making things they make simple things...

Quick Note
Posted by - on 06-29-04
hello all, annatar, the loving gaze of the eye? LOL. Perhaps in Mordor - but I wouldn't be accepting any shiny rings from you any time soon...

Re: Innovation
Posted by Nienna on 06-29-04
I also had that same thought about the elves and their lack of technology. Thousands of years and that's all they could come up with? But the elves...

Innovation Revisited
Posted by Annatar on 06-30-04
Nienna, yes perhaps they did foresee the damage such weapons could do and what might be required to make them. If such is the case, they only have...

Re: Annater and Dogs
Posted by Danny on 06-30-04
I find it ironic that you would praise dogs so highly seeing how badly Sauron got it handed to him by a dog. I recall a dog (Huan) nearly sent...

Huan
Posted by Annatar on 07-01-04
Danny I GAVE Luthien that puppy, I was glad to see him again and he was glad to see me. Like in times before, we had a little roll around and a...

Re: Annatar
Posted by Danny on 07-06-04
I am hesitant to bring up the analogy, but it so perfectly fits your reply about Huan. I recall a certain leader in Iraq a year ago who insisted...

The Last Ring-bearer
Posted by Nienna on 07-06-04
Hello to all people of the forum. I hope you had a wonderful holiday break. I have a question for everyone, it is known that Sam was the last...

Re: Danny and Nienna
Posted by Annatar on 07-07-04
Danny reading your post my fingers were twitching to reply from a different point of view. But then I read the second paragraph and had to agree.

Halls of Mandos, and Immortality
Posted by Bob Praz on 07-07-04
Just to correct you, Nienna, Men do NOT got to the Halls of Mandos. Iluvatar has something else planned for them after death. Death was, in fact, a...

The Undying Lands
Posted by Strider on 07-07-04
In response to Nienna, mortals who travel to Valinor and the Undying Lands DO die. They are just healed of all their hurts and sufferings that they...

Re: The Last Ring-bearer
Posted by RaggedyAnndy on 07-07-04
Sam would not live forever. Mortals who go to Valinor do not become immortal. They are able to live out the rest of their days in peace. So, Sam...

Annatar
Posted by Man Of Westernesse on 07-08-04
Great article as usual. "....Numptyhead Ahern ...." - hehehehe - a camera could'nt describe him better. On "Only those who don't want...

Thomas Covenant
Posted by Annatar on 07-09-04
Man Of Westernesse, I read two books on Thomas Covenant, I got to say I wasn't over the moon about them. Saying that, it was 12 years ago, and...

Fav Fantasy
Posted by Man Of Westernesse on 07-09-04
Annatar, Agree on Feist, Gemmell & Jordan - all worthy. I would add Stephen King's 'Dark Tower' very high up on that list - superior fantasy...

Decipher Cards
Posted by Strider on 07-10-04
Im just wondering if anyone has seen the cards produced by Weta and Decipher that people use to play certain game with and such.

Halls of Mandos
Posted by Eonwe on 07-10-04
I have been enjoying all the posts about the Undying Lands, my home. As many people have said, when mortals die they do not stay in the Halls of...

Decipher and Halls of Mandos for Men
Posted by Bob Praz on 07-11-04
In response to Strider, I have just seen the Erkenbrand and Ghan-buri-ghan cards for myself, and I agree with you: Ghan-buri-ghan looks like some...

Two Questions
Posted by Everett on 07-16-04
I have heard that in order to link The Hobbit with LotR, Tolkien had to change certain parts of "The Hobbit" to make the stories line up...

Reply to Everett
Posted by Bergil on 07-16-04
Tolkien did have to change the chapter Riddles in the Dark, to make it line up to LOTR because originally Gollum just let Bilbo go after he won the...

Re-make of LotR?
Posted by Bob Praz on 07-17-04
When the success of the LOTR movies became obvious, I started to wonder how long it would take for other filmmakers to have a shot at Tolkien’s...

This Week's Sign the Apocalypse is Upon Us
Posted by Everett on 07-17-04
I'm amazed. Simply amazed. Given our political differences (which may or may not be less than I'd assumed), I would never in a thousand years have...

Re-make
Posted by The Bruce on 07-17-04
When I heard that Star Wars was to be released on DVD, something caught my eye. The movie wasn't to be the touched up version from the 1990s...

Responses to Responses
Posted by Bob Praz on 07-18-04
Everett, I’m afraid I must disappoint you: I found the article thanks to a post on TORn about it. I’m afraid I don’t actually know the site (nor do...

Re: Remakes, and Lucas Vs Jackson
Posted by Danny on 07-19-04
I personally doubt that any remake that is ever dune is likely to live up to what PJ did. Unless of course PJ does the remake. The reason I say this...

George Lucas and Remakes
Posted by Tuor on 07-20-04
I would add maybe one thing to the Lucas v. Jackson dispute. In Lucas's defense, he was the original creator of the Star Wars universe, so he most...

I'm Back!!!!!
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 07-20-04
After 3 weeks of fabulous vacation I'm back!!! I caught up on the posts and found one that caught my eye. A re-make of LOTR- I think that would...

Lucas and Jackson
Posted by Lem on 07-21-04
I just caught up on the past week's polls, and I wanted to comment on the Jackson/Lucas fiasco. I think that they're not really very...

RotK:ee
Posted by Frodo_Lives on 07-24-04
I have a quick question: When exactly is ROTK:EE coming out? I have heard so many dates; November, December. I am so confused, does anyone out there...

Question for Annatar
Posted by Everett on 07-25-04
Annatar, what do you make of the available answers to the poll question? Also, PJ definitely should have included this:...

Lucas and Jackson
Posted by Eonwe on 07-26-04
I just saw the couple George Lucas/Peter Jackson posts from last week. I know the two were being compared as more than just directors - also as...

Re: Everett
Posted by Annatar on 07-27-04
About the poll, seems to me none of the wealthy, powerful or "wise" wanted to carry the ring and go into Mordor. Namely because they were scared,...

December 10
Posted by Lilly on 07-27-04
If you check theonering.net, you'll find comic con reviews concerning the ROTK EE (major spoilers, I may add). The release date was set pretty...

Hello All... Been Away Too Long
Posted by Pip on 07-27-04
Hey peoples, I've been gone so long from this forum, that I don't even know where we are any more... trying to catch up, but my attention span...

To Annatar
Posted by Elendur on 07-28-04
"9:Khamul" I suppose we have to balance the Fellowship out, don't...



Home :: Words :: People :: Images :: Links :: Forum

 
All content ©1998-2026 by the respective owners.
Not affiliated with the Tolkien Estate or New Line Cinema.
Adeptware