- Lord of the Rings movie news, photos, rumors, and more

Words - News stories
People - Cast and characters
Images - Image gallery
Links - Related sites
Forum - Moderated debate forum
Submit Article
My Account
Debate (2012)
Debate (2011)
Debate (2010)
Debate (2009)
Debate (2008)
Debate (2007)
Debate (2006)
Debate (2005)
Debate (2004)
Debate (2003)
Debate (2002)
Debate (2001)
Debate (2000)
Debate (1999)

Debate (2002)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26

Jackson's Variations of FotR
Posted by Kevin MacL. on 01-04-02
P. Megson's posting 12/30/01: The Bashing Starts makes this...

I Was There
Posted by Galahril on 01-06-02
I went to MiddleEarth twice in the first three days of Fellowship's...

The Revelation of Boromir
Posted by Claire B. on 01-06-02
I finally saw FotR last night, and I was stunned by its beauty and...

Posted by Dwayne M. on 01-06-02
I think all of you should stop being so critical of this film. YES, some...

For It Is In My Mind Also
Posted by Brett C. on 01-07-02
I will soon be seeing the movie for the fourth time and have been...

Arwen's Role
Posted by Fred P. on 01-07-02
When you asked for us to comment about Arwen's role in the movie, I...

Review of FotR
Posted by Rob W. on 01-07-02
This will be pretty harsh - but honest. I hope somebody reads it in the...

The Book Ain't Perfect Either
Posted by Razors on 01-07-02
Okay, everyone's been ranting on about LOTR and complaining - often to...

How Unfortunate for Rob W.
Posted by GiGor on 01-08-02
It is indeed unfortunate that you did not understand before seeing the...

Movies Suffer Slings and Arrows
Posted by Jamie B. on 01-08-02
As I was watching FOTR for the third time, It dawned on me. It was...

Variations by Kevin MacL.
Posted by Drew S. on 01-08-02
I have to agree with Kevin MacL. that Peter Jackson has produced a...

Good and Evil
Posted by Brett C. on 01-08-02
This essay is largely in response to Rob W wrote in his review. Rob, it...

It Was Pity That Stayed His Hand
Posted by Terry T. on 01-08-02
I feel real pity for Rob W. He's obviously being consumed by...

PJ Muffed the Ending a Bit
Posted by David P. on 01-09-02
I really disliked how the breaking of the Fellowship was changed in the...

Weathertop... Why?
Posted by Dan H. on 01-09-02
Everybody knows that things had to be different from the book. There is...

Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect
Posted by Andrea H. on 01-09-02
Hey, Razors, don't you fear; this is not going to be a death threat,...

Reinterpretation Makes Tolkien's Myth Come Alive
Posted by Chris P. on 01-10-02
I have loved the book and the movie both; for me the movie improves on...

Re: Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect
Posted by Peter C. on 01-10-02
I agree with just about everything the other guy said about LotR, but...

The Lost Fellowship
Posted by Brett C. on 01-10-02
Reading essays like the one by Dan H., who I think made some very...

Re: Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect
Posted by Razors on 01-10-02
First of all, an apology, I realize this is supposed to be a forum...

Ol' Tom Bombadil's Importance
Posted by Lisa C. on 01-11-02
I am re-reading the books for the fourth time. Thank you, Peter...

The Grey Havens
Posted by Colles A. on 01-16-02
I am a bit of a new Tolkien fan. Last year I have read the book for the...

Re: The Grey Havens
Posted by Brett C. on 01-17-02
Hi Colles. Always a pleasure to welcome a new Tolkien fan. Don't worry...

We Would All Love It to be 9 Hours Long
Posted by Christiane B. on 01-17-02
I have just logged in my forth viewing of The Fellowship of the Ring...

Re: The Grey Havens
Posted by Andy A. on 01-17-02
To Colles A. Now you come to the part where you will realize much of...

Sword Watch
Posted by Brett C. on 01-19-02
This is not so much an essay as a plea. I saw FOTR last night [5th time]...

The Magic was Sacrificed for Unnecessary Action
Posted by Gary W. on 01-19-02
My first viewing was a disappointment. The usual people talking all the...

Sean Astin: Unsung Hero
Posted by M.S. Molla on 01-19-02
I was a little disappointed to see that Sean Astin only received less...

The Sword That Was Broken
Posted by Lisa C. on 01-21-02
It is possible that the poster did show Aragorn wearing Andruil. That is...

Some Interesting Comparisons
Posted by Jobu on 01-21-02
I've seen FOTR twice now, and I thought it was fantastic. However, I can...

Some Comments for Jobu
Posted by Jamie B. on 01-23-02
First of all, Empire is by far the best star wars movie, and even though...

The Obsession Continues
Posted by Brett C. on 01-30-02
Thanks Lisa C. for replying to my need for more info Aragorn's sword...

Arwen as Mover of Events
Posted by Joseph W. on 01-30-02
I am pleased that the film reads apendix a back into the narrative, and...

The Uruk-hai
Posted by Sam B. on 01-30-02
Is it just me or does the infamous Lurtz the captain of the Uruk-hai...

Narsil and Anduril
Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-01-02
Back from my 4th viewing last night. It doesn't get any worse does it...

In Response to Arwen Note of 1/30
Posted by Chris B. on 02-02-02
One of the problems with replacing Arwen for Glorfindel is that he...

Re: The Uruk-hai
Posted by Peter C. on 02-06-02
It seems to me like Lurtz is there more as a general and all instead of...

The Importance of Character
Posted by Bethness on 02-06-02
I have to admit, I'm not as dedicated to Tolkien's works as some, but I...

And the Winner Is...
Posted by Brett C. on 02-06-02
Firstly thanks to Rag's Horn for keeping an eye out with the Anduril...

The Swords of LotR
Posted by Jamie on 02-06-02
I've seen the film a few times now and it was only recently pointed out...

Re: Swords in LotR
Posted by David on 02-07-02
I wanted to respond to Jamie's and others' concerns about the Anduril...

Movie vs. Books
Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-07-02
I've taken back my copy of FOTR and began to read it over again...

Re: The Uruk-hai
Posted by Razors on 02-07-02
I kind of see Lurtz as the Darth Maul of LOTR - a big, scary, nasty bad...

Belated FotR Review
Posted by Ken N. on 02-07-02
I have been reading both the criticisms and praise for the movie and how...

More Details
Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-11-02
About Boromir: "He was pierced with many black-feathered arrows...

Re: And the Winner Is...
Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-11-02
In the movie, the Argonath each hold up their landward arms, and Tol...

Dispute in Dispute
Posted by Brett C. on 02-13-02
Kudos to Rag's Horn - I saw the movie promo on TV the other day and...

Two Balrog Wings 'n' Drumsticks Please
Posted by Gothaur the Cruel on 02-15-02
Quick n to the point... Balrogs have wings. and heres why, first the...

Saruman's Downfall
Posted by Michael H. on 02-15-02
I saw a still in one image gallery of what may have been Saruman spiked...

The Final Word on Balrog Wings
Posted by Shaun A. on 02-18-02
The debate about wheither or not the Balrog had wings in the book shall...

Home :: Words :: People :: Images :: Links :: Forum

All content ©1998-2024 by the respective owners.
Not affiliated with the Tolkien Estate or New Line Cinema.
Adeptware :: Custom software development in Ruby on Rails, Java, and PHP