1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Jackson's Variations of FotR Posted by Kevin MacL. on 01-04-02 P. Megson's posting 12/30/01: The Bashing Starts makes this...
I Was There Posted by Galahril on 01-06-02 I went to MiddleEarth twice in the first three days of Fellowship's...
The Revelation of Boromir Posted by Claire B. on 01-06-02 I finally saw FotR last night, and I was stunned by its beauty and...
Rubbish Posted by Dwayne M. on 01-06-02 I think all of you should stop being so critical of this film. YES, some...
For It Is In My Mind Also Posted by Brett C. on 01-07-02 I will soon be seeing the movie for the fourth time and have been...
Arwen's Role Posted by
Fred P. on 01-07-02 When you asked for us to comment about Arwen's role in the movie, I...
Review of FotR Posted by Rob W. on 01-07-02 This will be pretty harsh - but honest. I hope somebody reads it in the...
The Book Ain't Perfect Either Posted by Razors on 01-07-02 Okay, everyone's been ranting on about LOTR and complaining - often to...
How Unfortunate for Rob W. Posted by
GiGor on 01-08-02 It is indeed unfortunate that you did not understand before seeing the...
Movies Suffer Slings and Arrows Posted by Jamie B. on 01-08-02 As I was watching FOTR for the third time, It dawned on me. It was...
Variations by Kevin MacL. Posted by Drew S. on 01-08-02 I have to agree with Kevin MacL. that Peter Jackson has produced a...
Good and Evil Posted by Brett C. on 01-08-02 This essay is largely in response to Rob W wrote in his review. Rob, it...
It Was Pity That Stayed His Hand Posted by Terry T. on 01-08-02 I feel real pity for Rob W. He's obviously being consumed by...
PJ Muffed the Ending a Bit Posted by
David P. on 01-09-02 I really disliked how the breaking of the Fellowship was changed in the...
Weathertop... Why? Posted by Dan H. on 01-09-02 Everybody knows that things had to be different from the book. There is...
Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect Posted by Andrea H. on 01-09-02 Hey, Razors, don't you fear; this is not going to be a death threat,...
Reinterpretation Makes Tolkien's Myth Come Alive Posted by Chris P. on 01-10-02 I have loved the book and the movie both; for me the movie improves on...
Re: Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect Posted by Peter C. on 01-10-02 I agree with just about everything the other guy said about LotR, but...
The Lost Fellowship Posted by Brett C. on 01-10-02 Reading essays like the one by Dan H., who I think made some very...
Re: Why the Book Cannot Be Perfect Posted by Razors on 01-10-02 First of all, an apology, I realize this is supposed to be a forum...
Ol' Tom Bombadil's Importance Posted by
Lisa C. on 01-11-02 I am re-reading the books for the fourth time. Thank you, Peter...
The Grey Havens Posted by Colles A. on 01-16-02 I am a bit of a new Tolkien fan. Last year I have read the book for the...
Re: The Grey Havens Posted by Brett C. on 01-17-02 Hi Colles. Always a pleasure to welcome a new Tolkien fan. Don't worry...
We Would All Love It to be 9 Hours Long Posted by Christiane B. on 01-17-02 I have just logged in my forth viewing of The Fellowship of the Ring...
Re: The Grey Havens Posted by
Andy A. on 01-17-02 To Colles A. Now you come to the part where you will realize much of...
Sword Watch Posted by Brett C. on 01-19-02 This is not so much an essay as a plea. I saw FOTR last night [5th time]...
The Magic was Sacrificed for Unnecessary Action Posted by Gary W. on 01-19-02 My first viewing was a disappointment. The usual people talking all the...
Sean Astin: Unsung Hero Posted by
M.S. Molla on 01-19-02 I was a little disappointed to see that Sean Astin only received less...
The Sword That Was Broken Posted by Lisa C. on 01-21-02 It is possible that the poster did show Aragorn wearing Andruil. That is...
Some Interesting Comparisons Posted by Jobu on 01-21-02 I've seen FOTR twice now, and I thought it was fantastic. However, I can...
Some Comments for Jobu Posted by Jamie B. on 01-23-02 First of all, Empire is by far the best star wars movie, and even though...
The Obsession Continues Posted by Brett C. on 01-30-02 Thanks Lisa C. for replying to my need for more info Aragorn's sword...
Arwen as Mover of Events Posted by
Joseph W. on 01-30-02 I am pleased that the film reads apendix a back into the narrative, and...
The Uruk-hai Posted by
Sam B. on 01-30-02 Is it just me or does the infamous Lurtz the captain of the Uruk-hai...
Narsil and Anduril Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-01-02 Back from my 4th viewing last night. It doesn't get any worse does it...
In Response to Arwen Note of 1/30 Posted by Chris B. on 02-02-02 One of the problems with replacing Arwen for Glorfindel is that he...
Re: The Uruk-hai Posted by Peter C. on 02-06-02 It seems to me like Lurtz is there more as a general and all instead of...
The Importance of Character Posted by Bethness on 02-06-02 I have to admit, I'm not as dedicated to Tolkien's works as some, but I...
And the Winner Is... Posted by Brett C. on 02-06-02 Firstly thanks to Rag's Horn for keeping an eye out with the Anduril...
The Swords of LotR Posted by Jamie on 02-06-02 I've seen the film a few times now and it was only recently pointed out...
Re: Swords in LotR Posted by David on 02-07-02 I wanted to respond to Jamie's and others' concerns about the Anduril...
Movie vs. Books Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-07-02 I've taken back my copy of FOTR and began to read it over again...
Re: The Uruk-hai Posted by Razors on 02-07-02 I kind of see Lurtz as the Darth Maul of LOTR - a big, scary, nasty bad...
Belated FotR Review Posted by Ken N. on 02-07-02 I have been reading both the criticisms and praise for the movie and how...
More Details Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-11-02 About Boromir:
"He was pierced with many black-feathered arrows...
Re: And the Winner Is... Posted by A Rag's Horn on 02-11-02 In the movie, the Argonath each hold up their landward arms, and Tol...
Dispute in Dispute Posted by Brett C. on 02-13-02 Kudos to Rag's Horn - I saw the movie promo on TV the other day and...
Two Balrog Wings 'n' Drumsticks Please Posted by Gothaur the Cruel on 02-15-02 Quick n to the point... Balrogs have wings. and heres why, first the...
Saruman's Downfall Posted by Michael H. on 02-15-02 I saw a still in one image gallery of what may have been Saruman spiked...
The Final Word on Balrog Wings Posted by Shaun A. on 02-18-02 The debate about wheither or not the Balrog had wings in the book shall...
|